Misrepresentation under the Indian Contract Act
Misrepresentation, alongside coercion, undue influence, fraud, and mistake, is one of the factors that can affect the freeness of consent in a contract. If consent to an agreement is caused by misrepresentation, the agreement is a contract voidable at the option of the party whose consent was so caused.
Definition and Provisions (Section 18):
Misrepresentation is an untrue statement that induces the representee to enter the contract. It is a false statement which the person making it himself believes to be true, and he does not intend to deceive the other party.
Section 18 of the Indian Contract Act defines "Misrepresentation". It includes the following types:
Unwarranted Statements: When a person positively asserts that a fact is true when his information does not warrant it to be so, although he believes it to be true. This is a positive statement of material facts made honestly believing it to be true, even if it is false. An illustration is the seller of a ship stating its tonnage without having seen it; if it turns out to be of a different tonnage, the buyer might be allowed to avoid the contract, as seen in The Oceanic Steam Navigation Co. v S. Dharamsey (1890). Another case is Dick Bently Production Ltd v. Harold Smith (Motors) Ltd (1965), where a false statement about a car's mileage was held to be misrepresentation allowing the buyer to recover compensation.
Inducing Mistake about Subject-Matter: Causing, however innocently, a party to an agreement to make a mistake as to the substance of the thing which is the subject of the agreement. Section 18(3) refers to this.
Key Elements of Misrepresentation:
To establish misrepresentation, the following elements must generally be present:
The representation must be made by the representor to the representee.
It must be a statement of fact and not merely an opinion, intention, or statement of law.
The statement must be false.
The person making the statement must honestly believe it to be true and not intend to deceive.
The representation must be made with a view to inducing the other party to enter into the contract.
It must have actually induced the representee to enter into the contract. The party must have acted on the faith of the representation. As illustrated by Peek v Gurney (1871), if the plaintiff did not rely on the statement but on their own investigation, they fail to prove inducement.
Distinction from Fraud:
The distinction between fraud and misrepresentation lies in the intent.
Fraud is an intentional wrong, committed with the intent to deceive.
Misrepresentation may be quite innocent. A false representation made without knowing it to be false does not amount to fraud. The person making the misrepresentation honestly believes it to be true.
Another distinction is in the remedy:
Both fraud and misrepresentation render the contract voidable.
Fraud, in addition, is a tort and can give rise to an action for damages in tort.
Simple misrepresentation is not a tort. However, Section 75 of the Indian Contract Act provides that a person who rightfully rescinds a contract is entitled to compensation for any damage sustained through the non-fulfilment of the contract.
A significant difference also exists regarding a defence:
A person complaining of misrepresentation can be met with the defence that they had the means of discovering the truth with ordinary diligence. This defence is available against misrepresentation.
This defence generally does not apply in cases of active fraud, though it may apply to fraudulent silence. For example, if a party could have discovered the truth by examining factory records, they cannot avoid the contract on the ground of misrepresentation. The case of Shri Krishna v Kurukshetra University (1976), while cited in the context of fraud, demonstrates a situation where non-disclosure was not fraud because the other party had the duty and means to verify the fact.
Effect of Misrepresentation:
The primary effect is that the contract is voidable at the option of the deceived party. The aggrieved party has the right to rescind the contract. If the party rightfully rescinds the contract, they are entitled to compensation for damage sustained due to non-fulfilment under Section 75.
The misrepresentation can also invalidate a guarantee obtained using misrepresentation made by the creditor or with his knowledge or assent, concerning a material part of the transaction, as per Section 142.
Furthermore, misrepresentation can induce a mistake about the character of a document, potentially giving rise to the defence of non est factum ("it is not my deed"), where the person signing is deceived about the very nature of the document. This principle, evolved to protect individuals like the blind or illiterate who are misled about the document's class and character, is distinct from a mistake merely as to the legal effect of a document signed with knowledge of its contents.
Limitations:
A crucial limitation on the right to avoid a contract for misrepresentation is that the party cannot avoid the contract if they had the means of discovering the truth with ordinary diligence. This implies a certain level of responsibility on contracting parties to verify facts where possible.
While the Indian Contract Act provides the remedy of voidability and compensation (under Section 75) for misrepresentation, the distinction from fraud, particularly the absence of a tort claim for damages and the availability of the "ordinary diligence" defence, means that the remedies available for innocent misstatement are less extensive than those for intentional deception. The framework under Section 18 and 19 focuses on restoring the parties to their original position or compensating for contractual loss, rather than punitive measures associated with tortious fraud. The presence of the ordinary diligence defence in cases of misrepresentation places a higher burden on the representee compared to situations involving active or intentional fraud. There are also suggestions to potentially broader statutory protections or remedies for misrepresentation in other jurisdictions (like the English Misrepresentation Act, 1967 mentioned in relation to compensation, or the discussion of unfair contract terms and unjust contracts under specific Acts outside the core Indian Contract Act framework), suggesting that the Indian Contract Act's provisions on misrepresentation, while fundamental, might be seen as a basic framework potentially supplemented or contrasted by other specific laws or judicial interpretations.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
