Mistake under the Indian Contract Act
Mistake in the formation of contracts means an erroneous belief about something fundamental upon which the whole consideration is based. When consent to an agreement is caused by mistake, that consent is not considered free consent. Unlike situations where consent is caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, or misrepresentation, which make a contract voidable at the option of the aggrieved party, consent caused by mistake generally renders the agreement void.
A contract that is void lacks legal validity and does not create legal rights or obligations. A void agreement is not enforceable at the option of either party. Mistake can operate on a contract in two ways: it may defeat the consent altogether, meaning there is no consensus ad idem, or it may mislead the parties as to their contemplated purpose. If mistake prevents consent, there is no consensus ad idem, and thus no contract.
There are three types of operative mistake:
Common mistake
Mutual mistake
Unilateral mistake
Common Mistake
Common mistake occurs when both parties to a contract are under the same mistaken belief regarding a certain situation or relevant fact at the time they enter the agreement. This shared mistake is about an underlying and fundamental fact. Section 20 of the Indian Contract Act provides that an agreement is void where both parties are under a mistake as to a matter of fact essential to the agreement. The Supreme Court has clarified that Section 20 is concerned with 'common' rather than 'mutual' mistake of fact.
For Section 20 to apply, the following essentials must be met:
Both parties to the agreement must be mistaken.
Their mistake must be as to a matter of fact.
That fact must be essential to the agreement.
An erroneous opinion as to the value of the subject-matter is not considered a mistake of fact. Mistake about the subject-matter of the agreement is deemed a mistake as to a matter of fact.
At common law, a common mistake will only render a contract void ab initio (from the beginning) if the mistake is fundamental. This includes mistakes relating to:
The very existence of the subject matter of the contract (res extincta). If the subject matter has ceased to exist at the time the contract was entered into, unknown to the parties, there can be no agreement. For instance, in Couturier v Hastie, a contract for corn that had perished before the agreement was held void. Similarly, a contract to assign a life insurance policy where the assured had already died was held void for common mistake (Scott v Coulson). This position is codified for specific goods in some Sale of Goods legislation.
A sale of property to a person who already owns it (res sua).
It's important not to confuse this with a situation where one party warrants that the subject matter exists. In McRae v Commonwealth Disposals Commission, where the defendant promised the existence of a tanker that did not exist, the High Court found no common mistake because the contract effectively contained a promise about the existence of the subject matter.
A common mistake as to the substance, nature, or quality of the subject matter may also be fundamental. However, a mistake relating only to the quality or attributes of the subject matter does not necessarily render the contract void. In Bell v Lever Bros Ltd, the House of Lords held that a common mistake about whether grounds existed to terminate service agreements without compensation related only to the quality of the redundancy agreement, not its subject matter, and thus did not void the contract.
Equity may provide relief for common mistake even when the contract is not void at common law, potentially setting aside the contract on just terms. This might occur if there is a common misapprehension of a fundamental nature, the party seeking relief is not at fault, it would be unconscionable for the other party to benefit from the mistake, and third-party rights are not unjustly affected.
Mutual Mistake
Mutual mistake occurs when the parties misunderstand each other and are at cross-purposes. There is no "meeting of minds" or consensus ad idem, as they agree upon different things in different senses. Thus, there is no genuine agreement at all.
The question of mutual mistake is determined objectively at common law. The court considers whether a reasonable person would infer that an actual contract existed between the parties based on the facts. The classic example is Raffles v Wichelhaus, where a contract for cotton "ex Peerless from Bombay" was held void because the seller was thinking of one ship named Peerless and the buyer was thinking of another, and a reasonable person could not determine which ship was intended. Because there was no correspondence of offer and acceptance, the agreement itself was void.
In equity, mutual mistake follows the common law. While rectification is not available as the parties never agreed on the same terms, equity may refuse specific performance or set aside a contract valid at common law in exceptional cases involving injustice or undue hardship.
Unilateral Mistake
Unilateral mistake occurs when only one party to the contract is mistaken, and the other party is aware of that mistake, or ought to have been aware of it under the circumstances. Section 22 of the Indian Contract Act states that a contract is not voidable merely because one of the parties was under a mistake as to a matter of fact. However, this general rule has exceptions, particularly when the mistake affects the very consent or is induced by the other party's conduct.
Unilateral mistake can relate to:
A term of the contract: If the mistake is of fundamental importance and the non-mistaken party is aware of it, the contract may be declared void. In Hartog v Colin and Shields, a contract for hare skins stated a price "per pound" when previous discussions were "per piece," a significantly different unit. The court held the contract void because the buyer must have known the seller's offer was made by mistake, given the industry practice was to quote per piece. However, there is doubt, particularly in Australian law following Taylor v Johnson, whether unilateral mistake as to terms can render a contract void at common law. The view has been expressed that once parties appear to have agreed on the same terms for the same subject matter, the agreement is generally good unless set aside on other grounds.
The identity of the other party: A mistaken belief by one party about the identity of the other party will negate consent if the mistaken party intended to contract specifically with a particular person and the other party knows this. Such contracts are considered an exception to the rule that unilateral mistake does not affect validity. However, this is often complicated, especially in face-to-face dealings. In cases like Phillips v Brooks, where A misrepresented his identity to a jeweller (B) to obtain a ring and then pledged it to C, the court held a valid contract arose between A and B, protecting the innocent third party (C). The scope of operative mistake as to identity is reduced when parties are in each other's presence. Identity must be of vital importance to the contract formation for a mistake about it to be operative.
The nature of the document signed: A unilateral mistake as to the character of a document, often brought about by the fraud of one party who fails to disclose the true nature of the document, can also be an exception to the rule that unilateral mistake doesn't void a contract. The defence of non est factum ('the mind did not go with the pen') allows a person who signed a document under a fundamental mistake about its character to say it is not their document. The mistake must be radical or fundamental, differing significantly between what was signed and what was thought to be signed.
Equity may set aside an agreement for unilateral mistake if it would be unconscionable for the non-mistaken party to take advantage of the other's mistake. This requires "special circumstances" such as the mistake being induced by misrepresentation, or the non-mistaken party knowing of the mistake and allowing it to continue or deliberately preventing the mistaken party from becoming aware of it. Taylor v Johnson is a key case where a contract was rescinded on equitable grounds due to unilateral mistake compounded by the non-mistaken party's conduct.
In summary, while the general rule is that unilateral mistake does not void a contract, exceptions exist, particularly where the mistake is fundamental and the non-mistaken party is aware of it or contributes to it, which may lead to the contract being void (in some specific circumstances like identity or the nature of the document signed) or voidable (in equity due to unconscionability). Common and mutual mistakes regarding essential facts generally render the agreement void under Section 20.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
