Mohd. Yashin gifted his dwelling house to his wife orally. Both were residing in the house. After one year, he executed a deed stating the fact of gift of the house to his wife. The deed was not registered. Whether gift was valid?
A Muslim oral gift of a dwelling house to a wife is valid without writing; a later unregistered deed that records it does not need registration.
The gift of the dwelling house by Mohd. Yashin to his wife is valid. Gifts of immovable property among Muslims are governed by Muslim law, which does not require a written instrument, and the later unregistered deed does not affect the gift.
The general rule and the Muslim law saving. Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires a gift of immovable property to be made by a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by at least two witnesses, and section 17(1)(a) of the Registration Act, 1908 requires registration of such an instrument whatever the value of the property. Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act saves the rules of Muslim law on gifts. Under those rules a gift (hiba) is complete when there is a declaration by the donor, acceptance by the donee, and delivery of possession. No writing is needed. The Supreme Court has applied this to gifts of immovable property (Hafeeza Bibi v Shaikh Farid, (2011) 5 SCC 654).
Delivery of possession when both live in the house. The requirement of delivery is met in a way suited to the property. Where the donor and the donee already live in the house, the donor need not leave it. What is needed is some real indication that the donor has given up control and the donee has taken it. A husband's gift of the matrimonial home to his wife, with both residing there, can be completed in this way, and the facts, including the passage of a year without any claim by the husband to the contrary, support the conclusion that the gift was made and acted upon.
The deed made after a year. The deed executed a year later records that the gift had been made. It does not create or transfer the right; the right had already passed by the oral gift. A document that merely records an earlier completed transaction is not an instrument which "purports or operates to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish" a right within section 17(1), and it does not need registration. Its non-registration does not call the gift into question under section 49, which operates only on the effect of a document that was itself required to create the right.
Cautions. If the deed was meant to be the gift, that is, if the parties meant the transfer to take place by the deed and not before, the gift would fail for want of registration. The facts here point the other way, since the oral gift came first and the deed refers to it as an accomplished fact. The oral gift route is available only to Muslims. Under Hindu law, a gift of immovable property needs a registered instrument.
Conclusion. The gift is valid. The deed is only evidence of a gift already made and its non-registration does not invalidate it.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
