"Past consideration is no consideration at all"
Differences between English and Indian Law on Consideration:
The main differences are:
Privity of Consideration: In English law, consideration must move from the promisee only. In Indian law, consideration can move from the promisee or any other person.Thus, Indian law expressly negatives the English doctrine of 'privity of consideration'. The case of Venkata Chinnaya Rau v Venkata Ramaya Garu illustrates this: an old lady granted property to her daughter (defendant) directing her to pay an annuity to the lady's brother (plaintiff). The daughter promised the brother she would pay the annuity. The court held the brother could enforce this promise, even though the consideration (the property grant) moved from the mother (a third party) and not from the brother (the promisee).
Past Consideration: English law generally regards past consideration as no consideration (with the request exception). Indian law recognizes past consideration, particularly past voluntary services under Section 25(2). Under English law, consideration and the promise ought to go together, and an act done before the promise is generally considered merely an expression of gratitude, not a price for the promise. The case of Roscorla v Thomas, where a warranty about a horse's soundness given after the sale was held to be based on past consideration and thus unenforceable, illustrates this.
However, English law developed an exception: a past act done at the promisor's request can be good consideration for a subsequent promise. The case of Lampleigh v Brathwait is a classic example, where a promise to pay for past services rendered at the promisor's request was enforced. This is sometimes explained as an implied promise to pay arising from the initial request. The modern three-part test for such cases (the act was done at the promisor's request, the parties understood that it would be remunerated, and the payment would have been legally enforceable had it been promised in advance) is stated in Pao On v Lau Yiu Long [1980] AC 614.
In contrast, under Indian law, the statement "Past consideration is no consideration at all" is not entirely accurate. As per the definition in Section 2(d), consideration can be an act that "has done", explicitly including a past act done at the desire of the promisor. Furthermore, the Indian Contract Act, 1872, specifically recognizes past voluntary service as valid consideration in certain circumstances under Section 25(2). This exception covers a promise to compensate a person who has voluntarily done something for the promisor, or something the promisor was legally bound to do. For example, if A finds B's lost phone and returns it, and B then promises to pay A Rs. 100, this is a valid contract under Section 25(2). This is valid even if the service was rendered without the promisor's knowledge or request initially, provided it was for the promisor.
It is important to distinguish past consideration from executed consideration. Executed consideration is an act done in response to a specific promise or offer, where the act itself constitutes both acceptance and consideration, happening simultaneously with the formation of the contract. Past consideration, on the other hand, refers to an act done before any promise was made.
Formality (Deeds): English law recognizes 'contracts under seal' (deeds) which are enforceable without consideration. Indian law does not recognize such an exception based on form; all promises require consideration unless falling under the specific exceptions in Section 25.
In summary, consideration is indispensable for valid contracts in India, requiring a return at the promisor's desire. While influenced by English law, the Indian Contract Act's definition in Section 2(d) and the exceptions in Section 25 introduce key differences, particularly in recognizing consideration moving from a third party and accepting past consideration under specific circumstances.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
