Performance of Contract under Indian Contract Act
Performance of a contract is one of the principal ways in which a contract is discharged. A contract consists of reciprocal and actionable promises. Once the parties have performed their respective promises, their liability under the contract comes to an end, and the contract is said to be discharged by performance.
The provisions regarding the performance of contracts in the Indian Contract Act, 1872, are primarily contained in Sections 37 to 67.
The relevant provisions are as follows:
Obligation/Duty to Perform (Section 37): Parties to a contract have a duty to perform, or offer to perform, their respective promises. This duty exists unless the performance is dispensed with or excused under the provisions of the Act or any other law.
Offer of Performance (Attempted Performance) (Section 38): Where a promisor offers to perform their promise to the promisee, and the offer is not accepted, the promisor is not responsible for the non-performance. The promisor also does not lose their rights under the contract in such a scenario.
Who Must Perform (Section 40 & 41):
Generally, the promise must be performed by the promisor himself if it appears from the nature of the case that the parties intended this. This is particularly true for contracts of a personal nature, such as an engagement to sing or paint.
However, the promisee may accept the performance of the promise from a third person. If performance is accepted from a third person, the promisee cannot afterwards enforce it against the original promisor. This principle aligns with Section 41 of the Contract Act, and has been illustrated in cases like Yaman v Changi.
Performance by Joint Promisors (Sections 42-44):
When two or more persons make a joint promise, all of them, during their joint lives, and after the death of any of them, their representatives jointly with the survivor(s), must fulfill the promise. After the death of the last survivor, the representatives of all must fulfill the promise jointly.
Any one of the joint promisors may be compelled to perform the whole promise, unless there is an express agreement to the contrary (Section 43).
If the promisee releases one of the joint promisors, the other joint promisors are not discharged from their liability, nor is the released promisor necessarily discharged from responsibility to the other joint promisors (Section 44). Case law, like A.R. Venkatasami Naicker v A.R.V. Jaganathan and Cm Bank NA v Standard Chartered Bank, relates to the performance of joint promises.
Time and Place for Performance (Sections 46-50):
Where no time is fixed, and the promisor is to perform without application by the promisee, performance must be within a reasonable time (Section 46). What constitutes a reasonable time is a question of fact depending on the circumstances. Cases like Saraswat Trading Agency v Union of India have dealt with this.
When a day is fixed for performance, and the promisor undertakes to perform without the promisee's application, the performance must be at the proper place during usual business hours on that day (Section 47).
When a day is fixed, but the promisor has not agreed to perform without the promisee's application, the promisee must apply for performance at a proper place and within usual business hours (Section 48).
When no place is fixed, and the promisor is to perform without the promisee's application, the promisor must apply to the promisee to appoint a reasonable place for performance and perform it there (Section 49). The common law rule that the debtor must seek the creditor and pay is in keeping with this section.
Performance may be made in any manner or at any time that the promisee prescribes or sanctions (Section 50).
Performance of Reciprocal Promises (Sections 51-54): These are promises that form the consideration for each other.
When reciprocal promises are to be performed simultaneously, neither party needs to perform their promise unless the other is ready and willing to perform their reciprocal promise (Section 51).
If the contract specifies the order of performance, that order must be followed. If not, the order is determined by the nature of the transaction (Section 52).
If one party prevents the other from performing their reciprocal promise, the contract becomes voidable at the option of the party so prevented, who is also entitled to compensation for any resulting loss (Section 53).
If a contract involves reciprocal promises where the performance of one depends on the prior performance of the other, and the party who is supposed to perform first fails to do so, that party cannot claim performance of the other promise and must compensate the other party for loss sustained due to the non-performance (Section 54).
Effect of Failure to Perform within the Fixed Time (Section 55): If a party fails to perform at the fixed time in a contract where time is essential, the contract becomes voidable at the option of the promisee. (This section is listed under "Contracts which need not performed" but directly affects the requirement of performance by a specific time).
Effect of Neglect of Promisee (Section 67): If the promisee neglects or refuses to provide the promisor with reasonable facilities for the performance of the promise, the promisor is excused for any non-performance caused by such neglect or refusal. An illustration shows this applies where a promisee fails to point out places requiring repair in their house.
The other sections under the chapter heading related to Discharge of Contract, such as Impossibility of Performance (Doctrine of Frustration - Section 56) and Discharge by Agreement and Novation (Sections 62-67), including acceptance of a less sum in satisfaction of the whole debt (Section 63). These are distinct modes of discharge but are covered in the same part of the Act as performance. Performance of contingent contracts (Sec. 32) is linked to the happening of the collateral event.
Specific performance is presented as an equitable remedy, distinct from damages, compelling a defaulting party to actually perform the contract. It is a discretionary remedy and is not granted if, for instance, damages are an adequate remedy or the contract is defective. Section 9 of the Specific Relief Act allows a defendant in a suit for specific performance to raise any defense available under the law relating to contracts.
While English concepts like the "Entire contract principle" and "Substantial performance", they note that the Indian Contract Act contains specific statutory provisions governing performance. Cases like Cutter v Powell and Hoenig v Isaacs illustrate these English principles.
In summary, the Indian Contract Act provides a comprehensive framework for the performance of contracts, detailing the duties of parties, rules for joint promises, stipulations regarding time and place, and the effects of non-performance or hindrances by either party, ensuring that contracts are fulfilled according to their terms unless legally excused.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
