'Relevancy and admissibility are neither co-extensive nor interchangeable terms.' Discuss. 'All admissible evidence is relevant, but all relevant evidence is not necessarily admissible.' Comment.
Relevancy and admissibility are two different questions. A fact must first be relevant. Then, even if it is relevant, the law may still stop the court from receiving it. So "all admissible evidence is relevant, but all relevant evidence is not necessarily admissible" is a correct statement of the Indian law, with one small exception that is explained below.
The Starting Point: What the Terms Mean
Section 5 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (IEA) is Section 3 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). It says that evidence may be given of facts in issue and of facts that the Act declares relevant, "and of no others".
Section 3 IEA (Section 2(1)(k) BSA) says that one fact is relevant to another when it is connected with the other in any of the ways referred to in the sections of the Act on the relevancy of facts. So relevancy is not just a matter of logic. It is a matter of what the law declares. A fact is legally relevant only if it fits one of the relevancy sections (Sections 6 to 55 IEA, which are Sections 4 to 50 BSA).
Relevancy is therefore the first question: does the fact have a connection with a fact in issue that the law recognises?
Admissibility is the second question: even if the fact is relevant, does the law allow it to be put before the court as evidence? Section 136 IEA (Section 141 BSA) shows how the two work together. When a party offers evidence of a fact, the judge may ask in what way the fact would be relevant if proved. The judge admits the evidence only if he thinks the fact would be relevant if proved.
Two Approaches to Relevancy
There are two ways of looking at relevancy. In England and the United States, every fact that is logically relevant can be proved, unless a specific rule keeps it out. Rule 401 of the United States Federal Rules of Evidence follows this approach.
The Indian Act is stricter. A fact that is logically relevant is not legally relevant unless one of the sections of the Act makes it so. A fact in India goes through three stages: logical relevancy, then legal relevancy, then admissibility. A fact that fails the second stage cannot be used, however convincing it may be.
This is why the two words cannot be treated as the same. Relevancy is the necessary condition. Admissibility is the further legal permission that the court needs before it can receive the evidence.
Relevant but Not Admissible
The law keeps out some highly relevant facts for reasons of public policy, privilege or fairness. These rules are found in the Act and in other laws.
Confessions. A confession by the accused is among the most useful evidence there can be. Yet it cannot be proved if it was caused by an inducement, threat or promise (Section 24 IEA, Section 22 BSA), or if it was made to a police officer (Section 25 IEA, Section 23(1) BSA), or if it was made in police custody without a Magistrate present (Section 26 IEA, Section 23(2) BSA). The Act calls such a confession "irrelevant", but in truth it is relevant and only inadmissible. In Dagdu v. State of Maharashtra (AIR 1977 SC 1579) the Supreme Court dealt with the working of these provisions.
Discovery. Section 27 IEA (proviso to Section 23(2) BSA) lifts the bar to a small extent. So much of the information given by an accused in police custody as relates distinctly to the fact discovered because of it can be proved. A confession that is otherwise inadmissible becomes admissible in this limited way if it leads to the discovery of a relevant fact.
Privileged communications. Sections 122 to 131 IEA (Sections 128 to 136 BSA) bar proof of some facts that are directly relevant. Examples are communications between husband and wife during marriage (Section 122 IEA, Section 128 BSA), affairs of State (Section 123 IEA, Section 129 BSA), and communications between an advocate and a client (Section 126 IEA, Section 132 BSA). The reason is public policy and the need to protect confidential relationships.
Statements to the police. Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (now Section 180 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) says that a statement made to a police officer during investigation cannot be used for most purposes at a trial. Such a statement may be highly relevant, but a law outside the Evidence Act makes it inadmissible.
Bad character. Section 54 IEA (Section 49 BSA) says that the previous bad character of the accused is not relevant in a criminal case, unless he himself has given evidence of his good character. The Act calls it "irrelevant", but it is really inadmissible. It is kept out because it would unfairly prejudice the accused before his guilt is proved.
All Admissible Evidence Must Be Relevant
The other half of the statement is that all admissible evidence is relevant. This follows from Section 5 IEA, which allows evidence only of facts in issue and relevant facts. Section 165 IEA (Section 168 BSA) adds that the judge's decision must rest on facts that the Act declares relevant and that are duly proved. Nothing can be admitted that is not first relevant.
There is one small exception. Some questions are allowed only to test the credit of a witness. Examples are questions in cross-examination (Section 146 IEA, Section 149 BSA), questions to impeach credit (Section 155 IEA, Section 158 BSA), and the use of former statements to corroborate a witness (Sections 156 and 157 IEA, Sections 159 and 160 BSA). These are allowed to test whether the witness can be believed, not to prove a fact in issue. In this narrow sense they are admissible without being relevant under Sections 6 to 55.
Section 136 and the Three Steps
Section 136 IEA (Section 141 BSA) puts the distinction into practice in three steps. First, the judge asks the party in what way the fact he wants to prove is relevant. Second, the judge admits the evidence only if he thinks the fact, if proved, would be relevant. Third, if the fact can be relevant only when another fact is proved first, that other fact must be proved first, unless the party promises to prove it later and the court accepts the promise.
A simple picture helps. Imagine a courtroom with a row of doors, one for each relevancy section. A fact can enter only through a door that fits it. Even then a bar may stand across the open door, such as the rule against confessions to the police. The fact must show that an exception has lifted the bar, as Section 27 lifts the bar of Section 25 when the information leads to a discovery.
Admissibility of Evidence and Mode of Proof
The Supreme Court drew a further line in R.V.E. Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu Viswesaraswami ((2003) 8 SCC 752). It is the line between the admissibility of evidence and the way in which the evidence is proved. A document may be admissible in principle, yet the way it is being proved may be wrong. For example, secondary evidence may be given where primary evidence was needed. An objection that the document is not admissible at all can be raised at any stage. An objection only to the mode of proof must be raised when the evidence is offered, or it is treated as waived.
Electronic records follow a special rule. In Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal ((2020) 7 SCC 1) the Supreme Court held that the certificate under Section 65B(4) IEA (now Section 63(4) BSA) is required when electronic evidence is produced without the original device.
Reliability
Even when a fact is relevant and admissible, the court's work is not over. It must still decide how much weight the evidence deserves. In Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer ((2014) 10 SCC 473) the Supreme Court dealt with electronic evidence, and the genuineness and reliability of evidence are judged only after the questions of relevancy and admissibility are settled. So relevancy is mainly the law's decision, while reliability and proof are the judge's decision.
Summary
A fact is legally relevant only if one of Sections 6 to 55 IEA (Sections 4 to 50 BSA) makes it so. Logical relevancy alone is not enough in India.
A relevant fact is also admissible unless a rule of exclusion bars it. Such rules are found in the relevancy sections (such as Sections 24 to 26 IEA), in other parts of the Act (Sections 122 to 131 IEA) and in other laws (Section 162 CrPC).
All admissible evidence must be relevant, except for evidence allowed only to test or support the credit of a witness.
An objection that goes to the root of admissibility can be raised at any stage. An objection to the mode of proof must be raised promptly.
After relevancy and admissibility, the court decides how reliable the evidence is.
The two terms work one after the other. One does not replace the other. The Act is built to make sure that only evidence with real value reaches the court, while protecting some relationships and interests that the law treats as more important than convenience in proof.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
