State the valid conditions of acknowledgement of debt under the Limitation Act.
The conditions that the statute itself lays down for a valid acknowledgment are four, and all must be present. They come from section 18, with sections 19 and 20 supplying the details.
The first condition is that the acknowledgment must be one of liability in respect of the property or right claimed. The section uses the words "in respect of any property or right", and Explanation (a) makes it clear that the exact nature of the property or right need not be stated, provided the property or right can be identified from the document. If a creditor sues for a sum that is different from the one acknowledged, the acknowledgment saves limitation only for what was admitted.
The second condition is that it must be in writing. No oral admission, however clear, has any effect under the section. The writing may take any form: a letter, an entry in a ledger, a recital in a deed, an entry in a balance sheet, a statement in an application or pleading. It need not be in the debtor's own handwriting, and the handwriting of the clerk who wrote it down is irrelevant if the debtor signed. Section 18(2) deals with the limited role of oral evidence. If the writing is undated, oral evidence may be given of when it was signed. But, subject to the provisions of the Evidence Act (now the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023), oral evidence of its contents is not received.
The third condition is that it must be signed by the right person. Under the section the signature must be that of "the party against whom such property or right is claimed, or by any person through whom he derives his title or liability". Explanation (b) says that "signed" means signed personally or by a duly authorised agent. A signature may be a mark where the maker cannot write, and initials are ordinarily treated as a signature. Entries in an account book that the debtor has not signed are not enough. The authority of an agent may be express or implied. It is a question of fact and need not be in writing. A partner in an ongoing business is ordinarily presumed to have authority to acknowledge on behalf of the firm, but under section 20(2) one joint contractor, partner, executor or mortgagee is not chargeable merely because another has signed. For persons under disability, section 20(1) brings in the lawful guardian, committee or manager. As for derived liability, it must follow the acknowledgment. A mortgagor who has already sold the mortgaged property cannot, by a later acknowledgment, bind the buyer.
The fourth condition is timing. The acknowledgment must be made "before the expiration of the prescribed period for a suit or application". It must be made while the claim is still alive (Sampuran Singh v Niranjan Kaur, AIR 1999 SC 1047 : (1999) 2 SCC 679). The prescribed period includes a fresh period earlier created by an acknowledgment, so a second acknowledgment given within the new period keeps the claim alive, and so on. Where the period has expired, the creditor's only course is to look for a written promise under section 25(3) of the Contract Act.
Beyond these four, there are two matters of practice. The acknowledgment must be pleaded and proved by the party relying on it. And the section does not assist in execution proceedings, because Explanation (c) provides that an application for execution of a decree or order is not an application in respect of any property or right.
Where the benefit is claimed through payment instead of a written admission, the conditions of section 19 apply in place of these. They require a payment made in time by the person liable or his agent, with the payment acknowledged in the payer's handwriting or in a writing he signed.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
