The only question for determination is as to if the lease required registration under section 17 of the Indian Registration Act or not. A had granted lease to B on the following terms: "Today, 1st January 1980, I have given shop on rent to B at a rental of Rs. 340/- per month, rent shall not be raised nor lowered, nor shall I eject him. But in case of his refusal to pay the rent, I shall have the right to turn him out". Decide and give reasons.
A shop let at Rs 340 a month with a promise not to eject except for non-payment gives an indefinite tenancy that exceeds one year and must be registered.
A lets a shop to B at Rs 340 a month. The document says the rent "shall not be raised nor lowered," and that A "shall not eject" B, except that A may turn him out if B refuses to pay the rent. The only question is whether the lease must be registered under section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908.
Which limbs are in play. The clause reaches leases from year to year, for a term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent. The rent here is monthly, so the third limb is out. No fixed period is stated, so the lease is not expressly for a term exceeding one year. The question is whether, on its true construction, it creates a tenancy that can last beyond one year.
The term protected by the document. The term of a lease, for registration, is the period during which the document protects the tenant against being turned out at the landlord's will. In this document, A has bound himself not to eject B. His only right is to turn B out if B refuses to pay the rent, and whether that happens depends on B himself. So long as B pays, he cannot be dispossessed. There is no fixed end, no notice period, and no event outside B's control that ends the tenancy. The tenancy is therefore of indefinite and potentially permanent duration.
Contrast with a terminable tenancy. Where a tenancy, though described as annual or indefinite, can be ended by the landlord at will or on short notice, the tenant's interest is never protected beyond the landlord's pleasure, and no term exceeding one year arises. Here the landlord has given up that power. A lease in perpetuity is necessarily a lease for more than one year and must be registered, and a lease for a period stated to continue until a fresh lease is granted is likewise treated as continuing beyond a year.
Decision. The lease is for a term exceeding one year and requires registration under section 17(1)(d). Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 independently requires a registered instrument for such a lease. If the document is not registered, section 49 bars it from being received as evidence of the lease, and its stipulations that the rent shall not be raised and that B shall not be ejected cannot be enforced. The terms of an unregistered lease are not a collateral purpose (Satish Chand Makhan v Goverdhan Das Byas, (1984) 1 SCC 369). B would be treated as holding a tenancy from month to month, which A can end by notice under section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, subject to any rent control law of the State.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
