The owner of certain premises let it out to tenant for a period of five years. The parties executed a lease deed, which was not registered. One of the terms of the said lease deed permitted the tenant to sub-let the premises to his friend Mr. 'X', if the tenant so desired, without the prior consent of the landlord. The tenant sub-let the premises to his friend Mr. 'X' without taking prior permission of the landlord, on which the landlord filed a petition for eviction. The tenant contends that in view of the term of the lease, he was well within his rights to sublet. The landlord contends that the lease deed having not been registered cannot be looked into. Decide.
An unregistered five-year lease cannot be used to prove permission to sub-let; the tenant is a monthly tenant whose right to sub-let depends on section 108(j) and State rent law.
A five-year lease has to be registered under section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908, since the term exceeds one year. The landlord is right that the unregistered lease cannot be read to prove its terms, but the same rule prevents the tenant from relying on the clause that allows sub-letting. The case therefore turns on what remains once the lease deed is set aside.
Effect of section 49. A lease that the law requires to be registered cannot affect the property or be received as evidence of the transaction unless it is registered. Its terms, including the term of five years, the rent, and a clause allowing sub-letting without consent, are not a collateral purpose that the proviso permits (Satish Chand Makhan v Goverdhan Das Byas, (1984) 1 SCC 369; K.B. Saha & Sons Pvt Ltd v Development Consultant Ltd, (2008) 8 SCC 564). The unregistered deed may be looked at only for a purpose that is truly collateral, such as the character of the tenant's possession.
What the tenant is left with. The tenant is treated as a tenant from month to month, whose tenancy can be ended by notice under section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Anthony v K.C. Ittoop & Sons, (2000) 6 SCC 394). He cannot rely on the deed to prove permission to sub-let.
The right to sub-let. That does not mean a monthly tenant can never sub-let. Under section 108(j) of the Transfer of Property Act, a lessee may transfer absolutely, or by way of mortgage or sub-lease, the whole or any part of his interest in the property, unless there is a contract to the contrary. So the tenant's right to sub-let exists as a statutory default and does not depend on the unregistered clause. It is, however, restricted by the State's rent control law, which in most States forbids sub-letting without the landlord's consent and makes it a ground for eviction. Where the premises are governed by such a law, the landlord's petition succeeds on that ground, whatever the lease deed says, unless the tenant proves consent by other evidence that does not depend on the unregistered deed.
Conclusion. The landlord is correct that the lease deed cannot be looked into to establish the term or the permission to sub-let. The tenant therefore cannot defend on the deed. The result depends on the statute that governs eviction: under a rent control law that prohibits sub-letting without consent, the landlord is entitled to the order; where no such restriction applies, section 108(j) allows the sub-lease and the landlord must proceed by notice to quit.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
