There is a contract to be signed between 'A', 'B', 'C' and 'D' on one hand and 'E' on the other hand. As per the arrangement the contract has to be first signed by 'A' and 'E' on 02.03.2013. Then 'B', 'C' and 'D' object to this by contending that the document can be registered only after 02.09.2013. Decide on whether the document can be registered on 01.06.2013?
There is no minimum waiting period before registration; a document signed by A and E on 2 March 2013 can be registered on 1 June 2013, and section 24 gives separate time for later signatories.
The objection of B, C and D is misconceived. The Registration Act, 1908 prescribes a time within which a document must be presented. It does not impose any period that must pass before presentation. The document can be presented and registered on 1 June 2013, and waiting until 2 September 2013 would in fact put the presentation out of time as regards the earlier executants.
The rule on time. Section 23 provides that a document other than a will is not to be accepted for registration unless presented to the proper officer within four months from the date of its execution. The period is an outer limit. A person who presents earlier than that, at any point after execution, is in time.
Several executants. Section 24 deals with the situation in the question. Where several persons execute a document at different times, it may be presented for registration, and for re-registration, within four months from the date of each execution. A and E signed on 2 March 2013. Four months from that date, leaving out the day of execution, run to 2 July 2013. Presentation on 1 June 2013 is well within that period. If B, C and D sign on later dates, section 24 gives four months from each of those dates as well, so that the document can be presented up to four months after the last signature.
Why 2 September is wrong. The date of 2 September 2013 is six months from the first execution. Nothing in the Act makes the document registrable only after six months. If no one else signed in the meantime, a presentation on 2 September would be beyond the four months of section 23 and could be accepted only if the Registrar directed it under section 25, which allows a further four months on payment of a fine, and only where the delay was caused by urgent necessity or unavoidable accident. Waiting would therefore put the parties at risk.
What the registering officer does. On presentation, the officer enquires under section 34 whether the document was executed by the persons by whom it purports to have been executed, and the persons executing it must appear before him and be identified. Execution that is admitted is registered. A person who has not yet signed has not executed the document, so the enquiry applies to A and E, who have. B, C and D, when they sign, may present it again for registration within four months from their signatures under section 24. Under section 32, a person executing the document, or claiming under it, may present it. B, C and D do not deny execution; they only dispute the timing, and their view cannot stop presentation.
Decision. The document can be registered on 1 June 2013, as to those who have executed it and appear before the registering officer. The time for B, C and D runs separately from the dates of their own signatures.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
