Contract ActLawful Consideration 12 May 2026· 5 min read

    Though consideration need not be adequate, it must be real. It must be something of value in eye of law. Examine

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    1. Consideration Need Not Be Adequate

    The Indian Contract Act explicitly states that consideration does not need to be quantitatively equal to the promise it supports. Explanation 2 to Section 25 provides this rule. It lays down that "an agreement to which the consent of the promisor is freely given is not void merely because the consideration is inadequate".

    The parties are free to settle any consideration they choose, and courts will generally not interfere simply because the consideration appears inadequate or too small. The adequacy of the consideration is something for the parties themselves to consider at the time they make the agreement, not for the court when the contract is sought to be enforced.

    Illustrations and Case Law:

    • Illustration (f) to Section 25 exemplifies this: If A agrees to sell a horse worth Rs. 1,000 for Rs. 10, and A's consent was freely given, the agreement is a contract despite the inadequate consideration.

    • The transfer of the goodwill and the whole of the assets of a business for only Rs. 1,000 has been upheld.

    • In Devji Shivji v Karsandas Ramji, the court upheld the transfer of a business for Rs. 1,000, despite the apparent inadequacy.

    • In A. Lakshmana Swami Mundaliar v LIC, it was held that consideration need not be quantitatively equal to the thing promised.

    • Thomas v Thomas (an English case) held that a promise by a widow to pay an annual rent of £1 was sufficient consideration for transferring a life estate.

    • Chappell and Co v Nestlé and Co Ltd (an English case) found chocolate bar wrappers to be part of the consideration for a record, emphasizing that the court is not concerned with adequacy if some value exists.

    However, Inadequacy Can Be Relevant:

    Although inadequacy doesn't void the contract per se, Explanation 2 to Section 25 adds a crucial caveat: "the inadequacy of the consideration may be taken into account by the court in determining the question whether the consent of the promisor was freely given".

    This means that if a party argues that their consent was not freely given (e.g., due to fraud, coercion, undue influence, etc.), the inadequacy of consideration can be a piece of evidence supporting that claim. "Inadequacy of consideration, may in circumstances suggest fraud, coercion, mistake, etc.". If the court is satisfied that consent was freely given, the agreement will be valid notwithstanding the inadequacy. The English case of White v Bluett, although primarily about value, also implicitly touches upon the idea that a truly valuable exchange negates suggestions of mere gifts or coerced promises.

    2. Consideration Must Be Real and Something of Value in Eye of Law

    While adequacy is not required, the consideration must have some legal value. It must be "real and not illusory". Where consideration is physically impossible, illegal, uncertain, or illusory, it is not considered real and thus is not valid. The English common law principle is that "Consideration must be of some value in the eyes of the law". This position is also adopted in India.

    An act done at the promisor's desire is consideration per Section 2(d). However, merely doing something at the promisor's desire might satisfy the words of the definition but not its spirit if the act is utterly devoid of legal value.

    Case Law Illustrating Lack of Real Consideration:

    • The classic English case is White v Bluett. In this case, a father promised to release his son from a debt if the son stopped complaining about the distribution of the father's property. The court held that the son's promise "not to bore his father" was too vague and unsubstantial to constitute good consideration. The son had no right to complain in the first place, and abstaining from something he had no right to do could not be consideration.The position is the same in India as in White v Bluett.

    • In Kulasekaraperumal v Pathakutty AIR1961MAD405, the Madras High Court observed that although the Indian Contract Act doesn't explicitly require consideration to be "good or valuable," it has always been accepted that consideration means something that not only the parties but also the law can regard as having some value. It must be real and not illusory, even if of slight value. The Supreme Court made similar observations in Chidambara v P.S. Renga 1966 SCR (1) 168.

    • The distinction between a moral obligation (like a pious desire) and legal consideration is that a moral obligation is not typically sufficient consideration unless it falls under a specific exception like Section 25(2) regarding past voluntary service, provided other conditions are met.

    Examples of Real Consideration:

    The examples of acts or promises deemed to have sufficient value in the eyes of the law:

    • Transfer of property in consideration of accepting responsibility for religious services.

    • A wife's promise to pay off her husband's debts and maintain his mother in exchange for enjoying certain properties.

    • A mother's promise to pay her son if the elder brother defaults.

    • A promise to pay bills if a guarantee was handed over, even if the guarantee turned out to be unenforceable (the handing over itself was the act).

    • Forbearance to sue for maintenance allowance.

    • Compromise of a pending suit.

    • An agreement designed to promote peace and goodwill among family members.

    In summary, while the law permits parties to freely determine the quantum of consideration (adequacy), it insists that the consideration must be something that the law recognizes as having value (realness). An agreement for nothing is generally not enforceable. This value must be real, not illusory, and can be an act, abstinence, or promise done at the desire of the promisor.

    Problem Questions:

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.