What are the documents of which registration is compulsory?
The classes of documents made compulsorily registrable by section 17 of the Registration Act, and how the exemptions in section 17(2) are applied.
Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 states which documents must be taken to the registration office. Whether a given paper falls within it depends on three questions: what the document does, what kind of property it concerns, and what value is involved.
Gifts and transfers. An instrument of gift of immovable property must always be registered, whatever the value of the property (section 17(1)(a)). Other non-testamentary instruments that create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish a right, title or interest in immovable property must be registered where the value is one hundred rupees or more (clause (b)). Below that value, registration is optional under section 18(a), though a transfer of such property can still be made only by registered instrument or by delivery of possession under section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Because clause (b) speaks of an interest "in immovable property", it does not reach movable property; a document concerning shares or a partner's share in a firm falls outside it unless it deals directly with the firm's immovable property.
Receipts and leases. Clause (c) takes in non-testamentary instruments that acknowledge receipt or payment of consideration on account of the creation or extinction of such rights. Clause (d) covers leases from year to year, leases for a term exceeding one year, and leases reserving a yearly rent. Clause (e) covers an assignment of a decree, order or award that itself creates such a right in immovable property. A lease or any other registrable document made by two papers must have each of them registered.
Agreements that affect the transferor's possession. Under section 17(1A), a document containing a contract to transfer immovable property for consideration must be registered if the parties wish to rely on section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act. If it is not registered after 24 September 2001, it has no effect for section 53A.
Authority to adopt. Under section 17(3), an authority to adopt a son, if executed after 1 January 1872 and not conferred by a will, must also be registered.
The exemptions in detail. Section 17(2) provides that nothing in clauses (b) and (c) applies to a number of documents. A document that does not itself create a right but only gives a right to obtain another document is outside clause (b); this is the reason a simple agreement to sell is not compulsorily registrable under the Central Act. A decree or order of a court is exempt, but a decree or order made on a compromise and comprising immovable property other than the subject matter of the suit or proceeding is not. Receipts on a mortgage for payment of money, if they do not extinguish the mortgage, are exempt, and so is a certificate of sale granted to a purchaser at a public auction by a Civil or Revenue officer. A recital of earnest money or of part of the price in a document that is only a contract for sale does not make the document registrable.
Decided cases. In Tehmi P. Sidhwa v Shib Banerjee & Sons Pvt Ltd, (1974) 2 SCC 574, an award directed one party to execute documents to transfer a share and pay a share of the rent. The Supreme Court held that the award did not itself create any right in the property; it only created a right to obtain another document, so section 17(2)(v) applied and registration was unnecessary. In State of Haryana v Narvir Singh, (2014) 1 SCC 105, the Court held that a mortgage by deposit of title deeds requires no instrument, and a memorandum that only records the deposit need not be registered, while a memorandum that itself creates rights and liabilities must be. These two cases show how the test is applied: the question is always what the document itself does.
Consequence. A document that falls within section 17 and is not registered is hit by section 49. It cannot affect the immovable property comprised in it, and it cannot be received as evidence of the transaction, except for the limited uses the proviso allows.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
