What is a Money Bill? What special procedure, in respect of Money Bill, is prescribed in the Constitution of India?
Meaning. The Constitution distinguishes three kinds of financial Bills: a Money Bill, a Financial Bill and an ordinary Bill involving expenditure. A Money Bill is a Bill that contains only provisions dealing with the following [Article 110(1)]: (a) imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax; (b) regulation of borrowing by the Government of India, or of any guarantee it gives, or amendment of the law on its financial obligations; (c) custody of the Consolidated Fund or the Contingency Fund, and payment into or withdrawal from them; (d) appropriation of money out of the Consolidated Fund; (e) declaring any expenditure to be a charge on the Consolidated Fund, or increasing such an amount; (f) receipt of money on account of the Consolidated Fund or the Public Account, or the custody or issue of such money, or the audit of the accounts of the Union or a State; and (g) any matter incidental to the above. The word "only" matters. A Bill that deals with these matters and also with another subject is not a Money Bill but a Financial Bill [Article 117(1)]. A Bill is neither if it deals only with fines or other pecuniary penalties, with fees for licences or for services rendered, or with taxes imposed by a local authority for local purposes [Articles 110(2) and 117(2)]. The expression "licence fee" should be read narrowly, as a fee collected through a licensing system and not a tax collected in the form of a fee.
Special procedure.
A Money Bill can originate only in the Lok Sabha and cannot be introduced in the Rajya Sabha [Article 109(1)]. It cannot be introduced or moved except on the President's recommendation, although an amendment to reduce or abolish a tax needs none [Article 117(1)]. After it has been passed by the Lok Sabha, it is sent to the Rajya Sabha for its recommendations, and the Rajya Sabha has fourteen days to return it [Article 109(2)]. If it is not returned within that time, it is deemed to have been passed by both Houses at the end of the fourteen days [Article 109(5)]. The Lok Sabha is free to accept or reject any recommendation of the Rajya Sabha. If it accepts one, the Bill is deemed to have been passed by both Houses in the modified form. The Rajya Sabha's role is therefore only recommendatory, and the final word in financial matters rests with the Lok Sabha, which is directly elected. Because the Rajya Sabha has no power to block a Money Bill, a deadlock procedure such as a joint sitting does not arise. After passage, the Bill needs the President's assent like any other Bill, except that the President has no power to send a Money Bill back to the Houses for reconsideration [Article 111].
Speaker's certificate. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha decides whether a Bill is a Money Bill, and his decision is final [Article 110(3)]. When the Bill is sent to the Rajya Sabha, and again when it is presented to the President, he endorses a certificate that it is a Money Bill [Article 110(4)]. The certificate has been held open to judicial review in the Aadhaar case, where the Constitution Bench held the Aadhaar Bill to be a Money Bill but the judges differed on how far the Speaker's certificate can be examined. Ashok Bhushan J held that the finality in Article 110(3) does not stop the Court from reviewing it, and Chandrachud J, dissenting, held that a Bill containing provisions outside clauses (a) to (g) cannot be a Money Bill. The question of the scope of Article 110(1) has been referred to a larger bench in Rojer Mathew.
How it differs from other Bills. A Financial Bill also originates only in the Lok Sabha and also needs the President's recommendation for introduction, but otherwise it is treated like an ordinary Bill, with full powers for the Rajya Sabha to amend and a joint sitting in case of deadlock. An ordinary Bill involving expenditure from the Consolidated Fund can be introduced in either House. It can be passed by the Houses as an ordinary Bill, but a House cannot consider it unless the President recommends it [Article 117(3)]. The distinction has a purpose: it protects the Lok Sabha's control over finance, since otherwise the Rajya Sabha could start a Bill that in essence is a Money Bill by adding some other matter to it. It also protects the Rajya Sabha, since the Lok Sabha could otherwise bypass it on an ordinary Bill by adding financial clauses and calling it a Money Bill.
Thus a Money Bill differs from an ordinary Bill in four respects: it starts only in the Lok Sabha, it needs the President's recommendation, the Rajya Sabha's consent is not required, and the Speaker's certificate is conclusive on its character, subject to the limited judicial review described above.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
