What is constructive desertion? Give examples.
The Foundation of the Doctrine
Desertion, as the Explanation to Section 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 makes clear, includes not only actual abandonment but also "wilful neglect" of the petitioner by the other party. The Explanation covers constructive desertion: a spouse who, by expulsive conduct, drives the other out of the matrimonial home is the deserting party, even though the aggrieved spouse is the one who has physically left.
The doctrine rests on the idea that desertion is a withdrawal from a state of things, not from a place. In Lang v. Lang ([1955] AC 402 (PC); (1954) 3 All ER 571) the Privy Council observed that the party truly guilty of disrupting the home is not necessarily the one who first leaves it. The party who stays behind may, by his conduct, make it unbearable for a spouse of reasonable self-respect and powers of endurance to stay, and is then the party responsible. He has deserted her by driving her out.
The Ingredients
Even in constructive desertion, both the essential ingredients of the matrimonial offence, the factum of separation and the animus deserendi (intention to bring cohabitation permanently to an end), must be proved. The practical difference between ordinary and constructive desertion, as Rayden observes, is that while in simple desertion the proof lies in showing abandonment, in constructive desertion the proof lies in establishing expulsive conduct on the part of the staying spouse.
The expulsive conduct must be grave. Irritating habits, domestic quarrels and clashes of temperament are part of ordinary married life and do not amount to constructive desertion. The conduct must go beyond blameworthy behaviour that causes unhappiness and be equivalent to expulsion from the matrimonial home.
A person is presumed to intend the probable consequences of his acts. If a spouse's conduct is such that he must know it will probably cause the other to leave, it is not easy for him to rebut the inference that he intended the departure by saying that he did not desire it.
Illustrative Examples
The following situations are recognised as giving rise to constructive desertion:
A husband who orders his wife out of the matrimonial home, or maltreats and turns her out. The departure is hers, but the desertion is his.
A husband who keeps a mistress in the matrimonial home, so that a self-respecting wife cannot continue to live there. The wife's departure is justified and is not desertion.
A husband who treats his wife as a stranger under the same roof, refusing all marital intercourse, so that she cannot go on. The husband may be guilty of constructive desertion even though he never left.
A wife forced to leave by persistent dowry harassment. The husband, and not the wife, is the deserter.
Unreasonable refusal of marital intercourse, where a spouse's unjustified persistent refusal to have sexual intercourse makes it impossible for the other to continue in the marriage, this may amount to expulsive conduct and constructive desertion, having regard to the circumstances of the case.
Constructive Desertion and Cruelty: The Overlap
Constructive desertion overlaps with cruelty. The same facts may be expulsive conduct for desertion and also conduct amounting to cruelty, and in Cade v. Cade ((1947) 1 All ER 609) it was recognised that the two can be hard to separate. Where relief is sought on the ground of cruelty, however, cruelty should be pleaded and proved as a separate charge.
The Reversal of Roles
Once constructive desertion is established, a later offer of reconciliation by the spouse whose conduct drove the other away does not by itself end the desertion. The spouse who was driven out may ask for reasonable assurances of genuine repentance and amendment before accepting, and is not bound to return to an unchanged situation.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
