Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam/Indian Evidence ActRelevant Facts & Admissibility 05 June 2026· 5 min read

    What is meant by 'relevancy of facts'? When are opinions of third persons relevant? Discuss in brief. Write a short note on relevancy, admissibility and credibility of evidence.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The Meaning of Relevancy of Facts

    Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (IEA) says that one fact is relevant to another when it is connected with the other in any of the ways referred to in the provisions of the Act on the relevancy of facts. The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) keeps this in Section 2(1)(k). So relevancy is not left to the judge's feeling or to logic alone. A fact is relevant only if it fits one of Sections 6 to 55 IEA (Sections 4 to 50 BSA). Section 5 IEA (Section 3 BSA) adds that evidence may be given of facts in issue and of the facts declared relevant, "and of no others".

    It helps to separate logical relevancy from legal relevancy. Under English law a judge asks whether a fact is logically relevant, and admits it if no rule keeps it out. Under the Indian Act the judge asks a different question: under which section is the fact relevant? If it fits none, it is left out. In Queen-Empress v. Abdullah ((1885) 7 All 385) Justice Mahmood observed that the Evidence Act in effect forbids the use of any evidence that the Act itself does not allow. So a fact may be logically relevant but not legally relevant. The opposite can also happen: a fact may be legally relevant under a section even if its logical link to the fact in issue is weak.

    The relevancy sections fall into these groups:

    • Facts connected with the fact in issue: Sections 6 to 16 IEA (Sections 4 to 14 BSA).

    • Admissions and confessions: Sections 17 to 31 IEA (Sections 15 to 25 BSA).

    • Statements by persons who cannot be called as witnesses: Sections 32 and 33 IEA (Sections 26 and 27 BSA).

    • Statements made under special circumstances: Sections 34 to 39 IEA (Sections 28 to 33 BSA).

    • Judgments of courts: Sections 40 to 44 IEA (Sections 34 to 38 BSA).

    • Opinions of third persons: Sections 45 to 51 IEA (Sections 39 to 45 BSA).

    • Character: Sections 52 to 55 IEA (Sections 46 to 50 BSA).

    Opinions of Third Persons: When Relevant

    The general rule is that a witness speaks only of facts that he knows himself. He tells the court what he saw or heard, and the court draws the conclusions. His opinion is not evidence. But the Act makes exceptions in Sections 45 to 51 IEA (Sections 39 to 45 BSA), under the heading "Opinions of third persons when relevant". The reason is that on some subjects the court cannot reach a sound conclusion without help from people who have special knowledge.

    Expert Opinion (Section 45 IEA / Section 39 BSA)

    The main provision is Section 45 IEA. When the court has to form an opinion on a point of foreign law, science, art, or the identity of handwriting or finger impressions, the opinions of persons specially skilled in the subject are relevant. These persons are called experts. For example, if the question is whether A died by poison, the opinions of experts on the effects of that poison are relevant. If the question is whether a document was written by A, the opinion of a handwriting expert is relevant. Section 39 BSA carries this forward and widens it to cover any other field.

    In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Jai Lal (AIR 1999 SC 3318) the Supreme Court held that an expert's opinion is not conclusive. It only helps the court. The court is not bound to accept it and must weigh it with the other evidence, using its own judgment.

    Section 39 BSA also covers the opinion of an Examiner of Electronic Evidence (Section 45A IEA, added by the Information Technology Act, 2000). The examiner is an expert notified under Section 79A of that Act. His opinion is relevant when the court has to decide a question about information sent or stored in a computer or in electronic form.

    Opinion as to Handwriting (Section 47 IEA / Section 41 BSA)

    When the court has to decide who wrote or signed a document, the opinion of a person who knows that person's handwriting is relevant. The Explanation says a person knows the handwriting if he has seen the writer write, or has received documents from the writer in reply to letters written to him, or has regularly received documents written by the writer in the ordinary course of business. This person need not be an expert. But he must truly know the handwriting. His evidence is accepted, though it usually carries less weight than the opinion of a trained handwriting expert under Section 45.

    Opinion as to General Custom or Right (Section 48 IEA / Section 42 BSA)

    When the court has to decide whether a general custom or right exists, the opinions of people who would be likely to know of it are relevant. A "general" custom or right includes one common to a large class of persons. For example, if the question is whether the villagers of a certain village have a right to draw water from a well, elderly villagers who would know of the practice can give their opinion.

    Opinion as to Usages, Tenets, etc. (Section 49 IEA / Section 43 BSA)

    When the court has to decide on the usages and tenets of a body of men or a family, the constitution and government of a religious or charitable foundation, or the meaning of words used in a particular place or by a particular class of people, the opinions of persons with special means of knowledge are relevant. This is useful in disputes over religious endowments, caste usages and trade terms.

    Opinion on Relationship (Section 50 IEA / Section 44 BSA)

    When the court has to decide the relationship of one person to another, the opinion of a person who has special means of knowledge, such as a family member, is relevant if it is shown by his conduct. In Dalgobinda v. Nimai Charan Misra (AIR 1959 SC 914) the Supreme Court explained that "opinion" here means a belief formed on the question, and it must show itself in conduct. Mere words, gossip or general reputation are not enough. The section has a proviso: such opinion is not enough to prove a marriage in proceedings under the Indian Divorce Act or in prosecutions for bigamy.

    Grounds of Opinion (Section 51 IEA / Section 45 BSA)

    Whenever the opinion of a living person is relevant, the grounds on which it is based are also relevant. So an expert cannot just announce a conclusion. He must explain the tests, experiments or reasoning behind it. If his reasons are weak or do not support the conclusion, the opinion has little value.

    Relevancy, Admissibility and Credibility: A Short Note

    Evidence must pass three tests before it can influence the result of a case. These are relevancy, admissibility and credibility. They are linked but different, and mixing them up leads to mistakes.

    Relevancy

    Relevancy is the first question: should the court consider this fact at all? A fact is relevant if it comes within Sections 6 to 55 IEA (Sections 4 to 50 BSA). A relevant fact may be proved, and the judge cannot reject it just because he is not impressed by it. In India the journey begins with the Act, not with logic alone.

    Admissibility

    Admissibility is the second question. A relevant fact may still be inadmissible if a rule of exclusion applies to it. Communications between husband and wife, evidence about affairs of State, official communications and professional communications (Sections 122 to 126 IEA, which are Sections 128 to 132 BSA) are an example. They may be relevant, but the law bars their proof to serve public interest or to protect confidential relationships.

    The opposite can also be true. Some evidence is admissible although it is not relevant in the strict sense. Questions that test or damage the credit of a witness (Sections 146 and 155 IEA, which are Sections 149 and 158 BSA), and former statements used to support a witness (Section 157 IEA, Section 160 BSA), are examples. In Ram Bihari Yadav v. State of Bihar (AIR 1998 SC 1850) the Supreme Court recognised that relevant facts are often not admissible and that admissible facts may not be relevant, as with questions asked in cross-examination only to test the truth of a witness.

    Section 136 IEA (Section 141 BSA) makes the judge the gatekeeper. When a party offers evidence of a fact, the judge may ask how the fact would be relevant if proved, and admits it only if it would be. Admissibility presupposes relevancy, but relevancy alone does not make evidence admissible.

    This has a practical effect. An objection to the mode of proof of a document must be made when the evidence is offered, or it is treated as waived. An objection that the evidence is inadmissible in law can be raised at any stage. Arguments about the weight of the evidence can be made right up to the final hearing.

    Credibility

    Credibility is the last question. Once evidence is relevant and admissible, the court decides how much weight to give it. This is a question of fact. The court looks at the witness's manner, the consistency of his account, other evidence that supports him, his chance to observe, and how likely his statement is.

    Section 3 IEA (Section 2(1)(j) BSA) says a fact is proved when, after considering the "matters before it", the court believes it to exist or thinks its existence so probable that a prudent man would act on it. The word "matters" is wider than "evidence". It lets the court take into account things such as the demeanour of a witness, which a written record cannot fully show.

    ConceptQuestion AnsweredGoverned By
    RelevancyShould the court consider this fact at all?Sections 6 to 55 IEA / Sections 4 to 50 BSA
    AdmissibilityCan the court legally receive this fact in evidence?Rules of exclusion (such as Sections 24 to 26 and 122 to 126 IEA)
    CredibilityHow much weight does this fact deserve?The court's judgment on the facts (Section 3 IEA / Section 2(1)(j) BSA)

    An example shows how the three differ. A confession made to a police officer, under a promise of pardon, is relevant because it is the accused's own statement. But it is inadmissible under Sections 24 and 25 IEA (Sections 22 and 23 BSA). Even a confession that is both relevant and admissible may have little credibility if it was later retracted or is contradicted by other evidence. These are three separate questions, and each has its own rules.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.