What is the constitutional concept of 'Minority'. What are the constitutionally guaranteed minority rights? Refer to relevant case-law.
The Constitution speaks of minorities in two Articles of Part III, Articles 29 and 30, but it does not define the word. The meaning has therefore been worked out by the Supreme Court, and the guaranteed rights have been shaped by the same process.
The rights. Article 29(1) says that any section of the citizens residing in India which has a distinct language, script or culture of its own has the right to conserve it. It is a right of citizens, and it is not limited to minorities as such. Article 29(2) provides that no citizen shall be denied admission into any educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds on grounds only of religion, race, caste or language. Article 30(1) gives all minorities, whether based on religion or language, the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Article 30(2) prevents the State, in granting aid to educational institutions, from discriminating against an institution on the ground that it is under the management of a minority, whether based on religion or language.
Who is a minority. The first question that arose was a minority in relation to what. In Re Kerala Education Bill, AIR 1958 SC 956, the Court was faced with the question of what a minority is to be measured against. In DAV College, Jullundur v State of Punjab, AIR 1971 SC 1737, the Court held that a minority has to be determined by reference to the population of the State and not of the country. On that reasoning Hindus, and within them the Arya Samajists, were treated as a religious minority in Punjab for the purposes of the Article. The point was settled in T M A Pai Foundation v State of Karnataka, (2002) 8 SCC 481 : AIR 2003 SC 355, in which eleven judges held that the State is the unit for deciding both linguistic and religious minorities. Ruma Pal J dissented on this aspect. The same approach was followed in P A Inamdar v State of Maharashtra, (2005) 6 SCC 537 : AIR 2005 SC 3226. In S K Patro, AIR 1970 SC 259, the Court spoke of persons residing in India in dealing with the protection under Article 30, and the Article is not confined to citizens in its wording. Certain groups have been considered separately, for example Anglo-Indians, and a Jain sect, the Swetambar Terapanthis. The National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004, provides a statutory forum for questions concerning minority educational institutions.
What the right to "establish and administer" means. The words "establish" and "administer" are read together. A minority can claim to administer an institution only if it established it. In the Aligarh Muslim University case, Azeez Basha, the Court held that the University, having been established by a statute, was not established by the Muslim community, and a statute regulating its administration could not be tested under Article 30(1). Parliament tried to meet this by amending the Act in 1981, but the Allahabad High Court in Aligarh Muslim University v Malay Shukla held that the amendment did not change the basis of the earlier judgment. The question of what makes an institution a minority institution was referred to a larger bench, and until it is decided Azeez Basha remains the authoritative statement. One need not be a community: State of Kerala v Mother Provincial, AIR 1970 SC 2079 : (1970) 2 SCC 417, held that even a single philanthropic individual from the minority, with his own means, can found an institution. T M A Pai held that the right to establish and administer includes the right to admit students, to set up a reasonable fee structure, to constitute a governing body, to appoint teaching and non-teaching staff, and to take action if an employee fails in his duty.
Proof and abuse. The community claiming protection must show that it is a religious or linguistic minority and that it established the institution (S P Mittal v Union of India). The onus is on the person who asserts that the institution is a minority institution. Courts can look behind the claim. In Andhra Pradesh Christian Medical Association v Government of Andhra Pradesh, the Supreme Court said that the Government, the University and the court may "pierce the minority veil", because Article 30(1) is not meant to protect pretenders, and refused protection to an institution started as a business venture. The fact that a school was founded by a person of a particular religion does not by itself make it a minority institution, and a government declaration that an institution is a minority institution is neither necessary nor decisive. On the other side, receiving funds from abroad, or having some managers born outside India, is no ground for denying protection.
Limits and regulation. Article 30(1) is not subject to reasonable restrictions in the way that Article 19(1) is, but it is not absolute. The Court said in Re Kerala Education Bill that the right is not an absolute one. Regulations that do not affect the substance of the right and that are designed to secure the excellence of the institution and its proper functioning are permitted, and the right to administer is not a right to maladminister. Recognition and affiliation are so important to the working of an institution that the right under Article 30(1) would be diluted without them. In Frank Anthony, the Court said that regulations aimed at making minority institutions effective instruments of education do not impinge on the right, and in T M A Pai it was held that the conditions attached to aid must relate to the proper use of the grant and must not dilute the minority character of the institution. Article 30(2) forbids discrimination in aid. Other cases include Ahmedabad St Xavier's College Society v State of Gujarat, AIR 1974 SC 1389, on the spirit of Article 30(1), and St Stephen's College v University of Delhi, AIR 1992 SC 1630. A minority institution does not lose its character by admitting students from outside the community.
In sum, the Constitution protects minorities in two ways. Article 29 protects the culture of any section, and Article 30 protects the minority's freedom to set up and run its own schools and colleges, with the State as the unit for deciding who is a minority and with the right shaped by the need for establishment, proof and reasonable regulation.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
