What is the significance of period of limitation?
A period of limitation is the time which the law allows a person to go to court. Its significance is that it decides whether a court may hear the claim at all, and for that reason it is dealt with before the merits of a case are reached. The rule rests on three ideas that are older than the Act. The first is that disputes should come to an end, since a claim that may be revived at any time keeps every transaction uncertain. The second is that evidence decays, because witnesses die, documents are lost and memories fade, so that a court is least able to do justice on the oldest claims. The third is that the law helps the diligent and not the indolent, so that a person who sleeps over his right should bear the consequence.
The statutory foundation is section 3, which directs that "every suit instituted, appeal preferred, and application made, after the prescribed period shall be dismissed." The duty is imposed on the court itself. It does not depend on the defendant pleading limitation, and a court that decides a time-barred suit on its merits acts without authority. The Supreme Court has said in Noharlal Verma v District Co-operative Central Bank Ltd, (2008) 14 SCC 445 : AIR 2009 SC 664, that a court or authority has no power to entertain and decide a time-barred matter on the merits, and that it must dismiss it even where the other side has not raised the point. The same duty was stressed in State of Gujarat v Kothari and Associates, (2016) 14 SCC 761, where the Court held that the plea could be taken for the first time in appeal, because it was for the trial court to consider limitation on its own initiative.
The rule is not absolute. Section 3 is expressly made subject to sections 4 to 24, which allow time to be excluded or extended in defined circumstances, such as the closure of the court on the last day, legal disability, fraud or mistake, acknowledgment and the exclusion of time spent in a bona fide proceeding in a wrong forum. Section 5 permits condonation of delay in appeals and applications, but not in suits. The courts have accordingly refused to extend time by resort to general notions of fairness, because the Act itself marks out the cases in which indulgence is allowed.
The ordinary effect of the bar is on the remedy and not on the right. A debt does not cease to be owed because a suit to recover it is barred; the creditor may, for instance, retain a security already in his hands. The significance of limitation is therefore different in property cases, where section 27 provides that at the determination of the period for a suit for possession, the right to the property is extinguished. The Supreme Court in Prem Singh v Birbal, AIR 2006 SC 3608 : (2006) 5 SCC 353, described section 27 as the one exception to the rule that limitation extinguishes the remedy and leaves the right. The result is that limitation in this field protects settled possession and makes titles safe to rely on.
Three illustrations will show the point. A supplier who sues for the price of goods several years after the cause of action arose finds the suit dismissed without any evidence being taken, even if the buyer never mentioned limitation, because the court must itself look at the date of institution. A landowner who watches a stranger live openly on his land for the whole statutory period, and does nothing, loses both his right to sue and his title, so that the occupier may rely on the possession he has had. And a buyer who purchases a house from a person who has been in undisturbed possession long enough can pay for it with confidence, because an old and forgotten claim cannot be brought against him. In each case the value of the rule is the certainty it gives.
To conclude, the period of limitation matters because it fixes the life of the remedy, obliges the claimant to act in good time, spares courts the trial of stale claims, and in the case of possession of property settles title itself. It is for that reason treated as a rule of public policy and not as a mere technicality.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
