Constitutional LawRight to Constitutional Remedy-writs & PIL 01 August 2026· 4 min read

    What is the writ of Mandamus? Against whom it cannot be issued?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Mandamus is a writ that commands activity. It is a writ by which a High Court or the Supreme Court directs a public authority to perform a public or statutory duty which it has failed to perform. The writ lies to ensure compliance with such a duty, whether it comes from the Constitution, a statute, rules or orders having the force of law, or the common law.

    Conditions. The applicant must show that he has a legal right to the performance of a legal duty by the party against whom the writ is sought, and that this right existed on the date of the petition. The writ enforces existing rights and does not create new ones. The duty must be mandatory and capable of being enforced; a general duty or a broad mandate that cannot be performed is not enough. In the case of a statutory duty, no demand and refusal may be needed. The writ is discretionary, and the court considers the facts, the urgency, the consequences of granting or refusing it, and the nature of the injury. It does not ordinarily lie where there is an adequate alternative remedy, or where there has been inordinate delay.

    Purposes. Mandamus can be issued to enforce a Fundamental Right, when a public officer or the government has violated it, to restrain the officer from enforcing the order. In B Venkataramana v State of Madras, AIR 1951 SC 229, a rule of communal rotation which infringed Article 16(1) was disregarded and the State was directed to consider the petitioner's application on its merits. The writ also lies to enforce the performance of a statutory duty by a public officer, to compel any person to perform a public duty, to compel a court or tribunal to exercise a jurisdiction that it has refused to exercise, and to direct an official or the government not to enforce an unconstitutional law.

    Discretionary powers. Where the authority has discretion, the court cannot substitute its own decision, but it can direct the authority to exercise its discretion within a reasonable time and by sound legal principles, and it can quash an order where discretion has been abused, where the authority acted mala fide or without applying its mind, or took irrelevant considerations into account (State of West Bengal v Nuruddin Malik).

    Against whom it cannot be issued. First, a mandamus cannot be issued against the President or the Governor of a State for the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of the office, or for any act done in exercising them, because of the immunity in Article 361. Secondly, it does not as a rule lie against a private individual or body, unless the State is in collusion with it. This must be read with the developing law that the High Courts, under Article 226, can issue a writ to a private body performing a public function or discharging a public duty. A private body that is only engaged in commercial activity, such as the manufacture and sale of sugar, does not perform a public function and is not subject to the writ.

    Demand and refusal. The party complained against must know of its duty, and ordinarily there should be a demand for performance and a refusal. The requirement is not rigid. A demand is not needed where it would be futile because the authority already knows of the illegality charged against it and is pursuing it, or where the failure is of a statutory duty imposed on a public authority. In K Sudarsan v Commissioner, Corporation of Madras, it was said that in such cases the command of the statute must be taken as the demand, and the failure to obey it as the refusal.

    Continuing mandamus. To keep watch over its own directions, the Supreme Court has evolved the idea of a continuing mandamus. In Vineet Narain v Union of India, the Court issued a series of directions to make sure that the investigation of the cases in question was carried out by the authorities concerned, and it kept the matter under its supervision.

    Other limits. Mandamus cannot be used to enforce purely contractual obligations, except where the matter has a public-law element or involves arbitrary action contrary to Article 14. It will not lie to compel a legislature to pass a law, or to direct the government to make a rule, bring a law into force or notify a rule. The courts do not use it to direct that a particular policy or relief package be announced when it has financial implications, or to compel the grant of reservation. Mandamus is not available to enforce the payment of money due under a civil liability (Burmah Construction Co v State of Orissa, AIR 1962 SC 1320), although an order to pay may be made against the State to enforce a statutory obligation. It cannot be issued to enforce administrative directions that do not have the force of law, though there are exceptions, and it cannot be used to perpetuate an illegality.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.