Who can adopt? Who can be adopted? Explain the capacities.
Who Can Adopt: The Capacity to Take in Adoption
The Male Hindu Adopter (Section 7)
Section 7 of the Act is the foundation. Any male Hindu who is of sound mind and is not a minor, that is, who has completed the age of eighteen years, has the capacity to take a son or daughter in adoption. The requirement of majority is absolute. An adoption by a minor male Hindu is void ab initio, and cannot be ratified or cured after the person attains majority. The only remedy available is a fresh adoption after majority, provided all conditions are otherwise met.
The one critical qualification, and one that the courts have enforced with great strictness, is the requirement of the wife's consent. Where the adopter has a wife living at the time of adoption, he cannot adopt except with her consent. If he has more than one wife, the consent of all of them is required. The law has specified three situations in which consent may be dispensed with: where the wife has completely and finally renounced the world, where she has ceased to be a Hindu by conversion, or where she has been declared of unsound mind by a court of competent jurisdiction.
It is important to appreciate that consent here is not a mere formality. In Ghisalal v. Dhapubai (AIR 2011 SC 644; (2011) 2 SCC 298), decided in January 2011, an adoption made fifty-one years earlier was set aside because the wife's consent had not been established. The Supreme Court held that the wife's silence or lack of protest cannot give rise to an inference that she consented. Her mere presence at the ceremony as a spectator was held to be insufficient, the consent must be informed and affirmative.
Section 7 requires only sound mind and majority.
The Female Hindu Adopter (Section 8)
Section 8, as substituted by the Personal Laws Amendment Act, 2010, brought about a transformation. Before the amendment, a married woman could not adopt at all, a glaring inequality judicially recognized but incapable of being remedied without legislative intervention. The original Section 8 permitted adoption only by an unmarried woman, a widow, or a divorcee, or a woman whose husband had ceased to be a Hindu, renounced the world, or been declared of unsound mind.
After the 2010 amendment, the position is this: any female Hindu who is of sound mind and is not a minor may take a son or daughter in adoption. If she has a husband living, she cannot adopt except with his consent, subject to the same exceptions as under Section 7. The female adopter's right is now truly in equali jura, equal in legal standing to that of a male. A widow, in particular, may now adopt a son or daughter to herself, in her own right, without requiring any authority from her deceased husband or the consent of any sapindas.
An important procedural point concerns co-widows. Where a senior widow adopts a child, the consent of the junior widow is not required. In Vijaylakshmamma v. B.T. Shankar ((2001) 6 SCC 15), decided under Section 8 as it then stood, the Supreme Court held that a widow's adoption did not need the consent of a co-widow.
Who Can Give in Adoption: The Capacity to Give (Section 9)
Section 9, also amended by the Personal Laws Amendment Act, 2010, confers equal rights on both parents to give a child in adoption. Prior to the amendment, the right belonged primarily to the father, with only a supporting role for the mother. Today, the position is as follows: if both parents are alive, either of them may give the child in adoption, but only with the consent of the other. The consent requirement admits of the same three exceptions, renunciation, conversion from Hinduism, and judicially declared unsoundness of mind.
The section is emphatic that no person other than the father, mother, or a court-recognised guardian can give a child in adoption. This rule closes the door to uncles, grandparents, or other relatives acting on their own authority, a reform that significantly reduced the potential for exploitation.
Where both parents are dead, have completely and finally renounced the world, have abandoned the child, or have been declared of unsound mind, the guardian of the child, whether a testamentary guardian appointed by the will of a parent, or a guardian appointed or declared by a court, may give the child in adoption. But the guardian may not act unilaterally: he must obtain the previous permission of the court before doing so.
Before granting such permission, Section 9(5) directs the court to satisfy itself on three specific matters: first, that the adoption will be for the welfare of the child; second, that the child's own wishes have been ascertained having regard to the child's age and understanding; and third, that no payment or reward has been received or agreed upon in consideration of the adoption. This welfare-based gatekeeping places the child's interest at the centre of the inquiry, a principle that runs through the entire Act.
Who Can Be Adopted: The Capacity of the Child (Section 10)
Section 10 lays down four conditions, all of which must concurrently be satisfied for a person to be capable of being taken in adoption.
First, the person to be adopted must be a Hindu, a requirement understood in the wide and inclusive sense given to the word by Section 2 of the Act. The old restriction that the adoptee must belong to the same caste as the adoptive parent has been entirely abolished. Any Hindu, whether a Brahmin, a Kshatriya, a Vaisya, a Sudra, a Jain, a Buddhist, or a Sikh, may be adopted by any other Hindu, regardless of caste. In Kumar Sursen v. State of Bihar, the Supreme Court firmly declined to recognise the adoption of a Muslim child by Hindu parents, holding that however long the child might have been raised in the adoptive family, the religious qualification in Section 10(i) could not be circumvented.
Second, the child must not have been previously adopted. This restates the ancient rule of Hindu law that a person can be given in adoption only once. A second adoption of the same person is void.
Third, the child must be unmarried at the time of adoption. This condition is, however, not absolute, if there exists a custom or usage applicable to the parties which permits adoption of a married person, such adoption will be valid. The custom must, of course, satisfy the conditions of certainty, continuity, and reasonableness that any custom must meet under the Act.
Fourth, the child must not have completed the age of fifteen years at the time of adoption. Once again, the condition yields to a contrary custom. An adoption above that age is valid only if a custom permitting it is proved. A mere assertion of custom is not enough, it must be proved to have been continuously and uniformly observed so as to have acquired the force of law.
Finally, Section 11(iii) and (iv), and not Section 10, add the requirement that where the adoptee is of the opposite gender to the adopter, there must be a minimum age difference of twenty-one years between them. If a male adopts a female, he must be at least twenty-one years older than her; if a female adopts a male, she must be at least twenty-one years older than him. This condition is mandatory and admits of no exception, not even custom. All the conditions must be fulfilled together. Adoption outside the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 is governed by the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 and the CARA regulations (see Q.51).
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
