Constitutional LawEmergency Provisions 06 August 2026· 5 min read

    Who can proclaim the Emergency? Describe the effect of proclamation of Emergency?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Who can proclaim. The Constitution provides for three kinds of emergency, and in each the proclamation is made by the President. For a national emergency, the President under Article 352(1) must be satisfied that a grave emergency exists in which the security of India or a part of it is threatened by war, external aggression or armed rebellion. The proclamation may be made before the actual occurrence of war, aggression or rebellion. Though the President is the formal authority, the effective power lies with the Union Cabinet. Under Article 352(3), the President cannot issue the proclamation unless the decision of the Union Cabinet has been communicated to him in writing. This provision was added after 1975, when the emergency was proclaimed on the advice of the Prime Minister alone. For the breakdown of constitutional machinery in a State, the President issues the proclamation under Article 356 on the Governor's report or otherwise, and for a financial emergency under Article 360 the President again issues the proclamation.

    Effects of a national emergency. The proclamation must be laid before Parliament and approved within one month, by a special majority of each House, and must be renewed every six months. It may be revoked by the President at any time and must be revoked if the Lok Sabha disapproves. The principal effects are these.

    First, the legislative relationship changes. Parliament can legislate on any matter in the State List, and a Union law prevails over a State law on such a matter [Articles 250 and 251]. A law made on a State subject ceases to have effect six months after the emergency ends.

    Second, the Union can give directions to the States on how they are to exercise their executive power, and Parliament can confer powers and duties on Union officers on any matter [Article 353]. Where the emergency applies to only a part of India, these powers can reach other States where activities there threaten the security of India.

    Third, the President may modify the distribution of revenue between the Union and States for the duration of the emergency, with the order lasting at most to the end of that financial year [Article 354].

    Fourth, the term of the Lok Sabha and State legislatures may be extended by a year at a time, up to six months after the proclamation ceases.

    Fifth, fundamental rights are affected. Article 19 is suspended automatically while the emergency is on the ground of war or external aggression, and by Presidential order the right to move the courts to enforce specified Fundamental Rights, other than those under Articles 20 and 21, is suspended [Articles 358 and 359]. The rights themselves continue; what is suspended is the remedy. Laws made during the emergency must recite that they are in relation to the emergency to get the benefit of Article 358.

    Fundamental Rights during an emergency: the cases. Before the Forty-fourth Amendment, Article 19 was suspended automatically on the proclamation, and Article 358 saved the laws and executive actions of the period from challenge under it, even after the emergency ended. Article 359 did not suspend the rights themselves but only the right to move the courts to enforce them, and only if the President so ordered. During the emergency of 1962 the Presidential Order of 3 November 1962 suspended the right to move any court to enforce Articles 14, 21 and 22 where a person was deprived of them under the Defence of India Act, 1962 or rules made under it. The courts read this order narrowly. It excluded their jurisdiction only for actions taken under that Act and its rules, and an action under any other law could still be challenged under Articles 14, 21 and 22. In State of Maharashtra v Prabhakar, a detenu under the Defence of India Rules was refused permission to send a book manuscript for publication. The Supreme Court held that the Presidential Order suspended Article 21 only to the extent that a person was deprived of liberty under the Act or Rules, and that where the authority imposed a restriction in violation of the law under which the detenu was held, he could still move the court. The Court also held, in the cases on rule 30A, that an order confirming detention after the six-monthly review had to be recorded in writing, that a review made after six months made the detention invalid, and that the review was a quasi-judicial proceeding, so that the detenu then got a right to the grounds of detention. In Mohd Yaqub v State of Jammu and Kashmir, it was argued that the Presidential Order was a "law" under Article 13(2) and so could be challenged under the very rights it suspended. The Court rejected the argument, holding that Article 359 gives the President unlimited power to suspend the enforcement of any Fundamental Right, and that Articles 13(2) and 359 must be read harmoniously. Even then a detenu could still challenge the detention on the ground that it was mala fide, or that a ground mentioned in the order was irrelevant. Makhan Singh v State of Punjab, AIR 1964 SC 381, held that when the emergency ended, a person denied enforcement of a right could sue for damages, because only the enforcement, and not the right, had been suspended. To overcome this the Thirty-eighth Amendment, 1975, added clause (1A) to Article 359, which allows laws and executive action contrary to the suspended rights while the order is in force, with retrospective effect from the commencement of the Constitution. In the emergency of 25 June 1975, declared on the ground of internal disturbance, the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975 suspended the right to move the courts to enforce the rights under Articles 14, 21 and 22 generally, a much wider order than those of 1962 or 1971. ADM Jabalpur v Shivkant Shukla, AIR 1976 SC 1207, which accepted that Parliament could suspend all Fundamental Rights, including Article 21, during an emergency, has since been overruled in Justice K S Puttaswamy v Union of India.

    The result is that the State Governments and Legislatures keep functioning, but the Constitution operates in practice as a unitary one. In an emergency under Article 356, by contrast, the State Legislature is suspended or dissolved, and the State is governed through the Governor on behalf of the President, but the Fundamental Rights are not affected.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.