Who will succeed to the self-acquired property of a Hindu male dying intestate leaving mother, brother and married daughter?
The Survivors and Their Classification
The question speaks of self-acquired property, so Section 8 applies directly. The three survivors are:
Mother (M), expressly listed in Class I of the Schedule
Brother (B), placed in Entry II of Class II (alongside sons' daughters' son, sons' daughters' daughter, and sister)
Married daughter (D), expressly listed in Class I of the Schedule
The answer depends on Sections 8 and 9 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Section 8 provides that the property of a male Hindu dying intestate devolves first upon the heirs in Class I of the Schedule. Section 9 provides that those in Class I take simultaneously and exclude all other heirs, and that Class II heirs take only if there is no Class I heir. If the property were coparcenary, Section 6 would apply, but that is not the case here (see Q.28 and Q.31).
Class I Excludes Class II
The brother occupies Entry II of Class II. He can inherit only if there is no Class I heir. Here two Class I heirs are present, the mother and the married daughter, so the brother takes nothing.
The Mother's Place in Class I
The mother is a Class I heir, together with the widow, the son and the daughter, while the father is in Class II, Entry I. Had the father been alive he too would have been excluded by the two Class I heirs.
Distribution Among the Two Class I Heirs
Under Section 10, Rule 2, each surviving daughter and the mother takes one share. Neither represents a predeceased person's branch, so each takes one share.
The marital status of the daughter is irrelevant: a daughter, married or unmarried, inherits equally. Since the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, Section 6 also makes her a coparcener in a Mitakshara joint family by birth, as the Supreme Court held in Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma ((2020) 9 SCC 1).
The Final Distribution
| Heir | Relationship | Class | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mother (M) | Class I heir | Class I | 1/2 |
| Married Daughter (D) | Class I heir | Class I | 1/2 |
| Brother (B) | Entry II, Class II | Class II | Nil (excluded) |
The estate devolves in equal shares on the mother and the married daughter. The brother is excluded only because he is a Class II heir and Class I heirs are present; he is not disqualified.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
