Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam/Indian Evidence ActPreliminary 05 June 2026· 5 min read

    Write notes on the following: (i) May presume (ii) Shall presume (iii) Conclusive proof. In case of conclusive proof, can the court ignore a fact declared so under the Evidence Act, otherwise?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Section 4 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (IEA) is now Section 2(1)(b), (h) and (l) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). It gives three phrases: "may presume", "shall presume" and "conclusive proof". Each phrase tells the court how much freedom it has and what the other side can do about the presumed fact.

    I. May Presume

    The Act says that whenever it provides that the court "may presume" a fact, the court may either regard the fact as proved, unless and until it is disproved, or call for further proof of it. The key word is "may". It gives the court a choice, not a duty. The court can treat the fact as proved, or it can ask the party to prove the fact by other evidence.

    This is a presumption of fact (praesumptio hominis). It rests on the common course of events, human conduct and everyday experience. The law does not order the court to draw it. The law only says that in some situations the inference is usually a sensible one.

    The main provision is Section 114 IEA (Section 119 BSA). It lets the court presume any fact that it thinks likely to have happened, looking at the common course of natural events, human conduct, and public and private business. Some of its illustrations are:

    • Illustration (a): A man found with stolen goods soon after the theft may be presumed to be the thief, or to have received the goods knowing they were stolen, unless he can explain how he came to have them.

    • Illustration (b): An accomplice is not worthy of credit unless he is supported on the main points of his story.

    • Illustration (c): A bill of exchange that was accepted or endorsed is presumed to have been given for consideration.

    • Illustration (e): Court and official acts are presumed to have been done properly. This is the maxim omnia praesumuntur rite esse acta, meaning that all acts are presumed to be rightly and regularly done.

    • Illustration (f): A letter that was posted is presumed to have reached the person it was sent to in the ordinary course of post.

    • Illustration (g): If a party holds back evidence that he could produce, the court may presume that the evidence would have gone against him. This is called an adverse inference.

    The Supreme Court explained the word "may" in Sodhi Transport Co. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (AIR 1986 SC 1099). Where the court has an option, it may treat the fact as proved or ask for confirming evidence, as the case requires. This freedom protects against mechanical use of the presumption.

    Once the court uses its choice and does raise the presumption, the difference between "may presume" and "shall presume" disappears in effect. In both cases the fact is taken as proved until it is disproved. The Supreme Court said this in Kumar Exports v. Sharma Carpets ((2009) 2 SCC 513).

    One more rule applies to every presumption. A presumption must rest on facts that are proved. A presumption cannot be based on another presumption. The Supreme Court applied this idea in Suresh Budharmal Kalani v. State of Maharashtra ((1998) 7 SCC 337). The fact from which a court draws a presumption must itself be proved by evidence. A chain of presumptions, each resting on the one before, has no legal base.

    II. Shall Presume

    The Act says that whenever it directs that the court "shall presume" a fact, the court must regard the fact as proved, unless and until it is disproved. Here the word is "shall", so the court has no choice. This is a rebuttable presumption of law (praesumptio juris). Once the basic facts are proved, the court must raise the presumption. It stands until the other side proves the opposite.

    There are many "shall presume" provisions, especially about documents and a few serious offences:

    • Sections 79 to 85 IEA / Sections 78 to 84 BSA: The court shall presume that certified copies of public documents, court records, gazettes, maps made under government authority, and powers of attorney are genuine. These rest on the maxim omnia praesumuntur rite esse acta: acts done by public officers in their official role are presumed to be done properly.

    • Section 105 IEA / Section 108 BSA: In a criminal trial, the court shall presume that no circumstances existed which would bring the accused within an exception to the offence (such as self-defence). The accused who relies on an exception has to prove it. He does not need to prove it beyond reasonable doubt; it is enough if he shows it is more probable than not.

    • Section 113A IEA / Section 117 BSA: If a married woman dies by suicide within seven years of marriage and her husband or his relative treated her with cruelty, the court may presume that the suicide was abetted. This is a "may presume" provision. The law kept "may" here because not every such suicide is a result of abetment. The court must look at all the circumstances first.

    • Section 113B IEA / Section 118 BSA: This is a strong "shall presume" provision for dowry death. If the prosecution shows that soon before her death the woman was treated with cruelty or harassment for dowry, the court shall presume that the accused caused the dowry death under Section 304B IPC (now Section 80 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023). In State of Punjab v. Iqbal Singh (AIR 1991 SC 1532) the Supreme Court held that once these basic facts are proved, the court must raise the presumption.

    Both "may presume" and "shall presume" presumptions can be rebutted. The difference lies in what the court must do. With "may presume" the court decides whether to raise the presumption at all. With "shall presume" it must raise it, and the other side must then bring evidence to disprove it. That evidence has to be real and convincing, though it need not reach the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt.

    Other laws also use "shall presume". Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 says that every negotiable instrument shall be presumed to have been made for consideration. In Kumar Exports the Supreme Court explained that a presumption of this kind only shifts the burden to the other party, who can rebut it by evidence.

    III. Conclusive Proof

    The Act says that when one fact is declared to be conclusive proof of another, the court shall, on proof of the first fact, regard the other as proved. The court shall not allow evidence to be given to disprove it. This is the strongest of the three. It is the praesumptio juris et de jure, an irrebuttable presumption of law. In truth it is a rule of substantive law, and that is why the Act calls it "conclusive proof" and keeps the word "presumption" for those that can be rebutted.

    There are very few examples:

    • Section 41 IEA / Section 35 BSA: A final judgment of a competent court in probate, matrimonial, admiralty or insolvency matters, which gives a legal character to a person or takes it away, is conclusive proof of that character against everyone. It is the principle of res judicata carried into the law of evidence.

    • Section 112 IEA / Section 116 BSA: If a child is born during a valid marriage, or within 280 days after the marriage ends while the mother stays unmarried, this is conclusive proof that the child is the husband's legitimate child. The only way out is to show that the husband and wife had no access to each other at any time when the child could have been conceived. The rule comes from the old maxim pater est quem nuptiae demonstrant (the father is the man whom the marriage points to). The reason is public policy: the law protects the legitimacy of children and the marriage itself.

    • Section 113 IEA: A notification in the Official Gazette that British territory was handed over to a Native State is conclusive proof that it was validly handed over. The BSA has dropped this section.

    Can the Court Ignore a Fact Declared to be Conclusive Proof?

    The short answer is no. The Act says the court "shall" regard the second fact as proved and "shall not allow" evidence to disprove it. Both are commands. The court has no room to ignore the conclusive fact, either on its own or because strong evidence points the other way. If it did, it would act against a clear order of the law.

    In Sodhi Transport the Supreme Court looked at Sections 41, 112 and 113. It said these are cases where the law holds that no amount of other evidence will change the result once the basic facts are admitted or proved. Once the door is closed, it stays closed.

    There is one puzzle. Section 112 uses the words "conclusive proof" but also allows proof of non-access between husband and wife. How can a conclusive presumption be disproved? The courts have answered that the presumption can be removed only by proving the one fact the section itself names, which is non-access. In Chilukuri Venkateswarlu v. Chilukuri Venkatanarayana (AIR 1954 SC 176) the Supreme Court held that the presumption of Section 112 can be displaced only by proof of non-access. In Goutam Kundu v. State of West Bengal (AIR 1993 SC 2295) the Court also stressed that the presumption is a strong one and cannot be displaced lightly.

    DNA testing has made this question harder. In Nandlal Wasudeo Badwaik v. Lata Nandlal Badwaik ((2014) 2 SCC 576) the DNA report showed that the husband was not the father of the child. The Supreme Court held that where a conclusive presumption of law conflicts with a result of scientific testing that is accepted as correct, the scientific result should prevail. The Court did not say that Section 112 can be ignored whenever a DNA report is available. It decided on the facts before it.

    In Bhabani Prasad Jena v. Convenor Secretary, Orissa State Commission for Women ((2010) 8 SCC 633) the Supreme Court warned that a DNA test should not be ordered as a matter of routine. The court must first consider the presumption under Section 112, and ask whether it can reach the truth without such a test. It must balance the right to know the truth, the interest of the child, the privacy of the parties and the presumption itself.

    The position can be summed up in four points:

    1. A court cannot ignore a fact that the Act declares to be conclusive proof.

    2. A court cannot allow evidence to disprove a conclusive presumption. The bar in the definition is absolute.

    3. Where the section itself gives a narrow exception, as Section 112 does for non-access, only that exception can be used. It cannot be widened by general arguments.

    4. In rare cases, where modern scientific evidence such as DNA is involved, the courts have let the scientific result prevail. This is still debated, and it must never become a routine way to defeat the presumption.

    In Sham Lal v. Sanjeev Kumar ((2009) 12 SCC 454) the Supreme Court recalled that Section 112 rests on public policy and public morality. The law leans in favour of the legitimacy of a child born in a valid marriage, because branding a child illegitimate without clear proof harms both the child and society.

    A Comparison

    FeatureMay Presume (S.114 IEA / S.119 BSA)Shall Presume (S.79 to 85 IEA / S.78 to 84 BSA, and others)Conclusive Proof (S.41, 112 IEA / S.35, 116 BSA)
    NaturePresumption of factPresumption of lawPresumption of law
    Court's roleHas a choiceMust raise itMust raise it and must not allow it to be disproved
    Can it be rebutted?YesYesNo, except through the section's own exception
    Latin termPraesumptio hominisPraesumptio jurisPraesumptio juris et de jure
    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.