Write short note on the following: The concept of separation of powers in the Constitution of India.
The idea of separation of powers belongs to the theory of constitutional government. It is usually traced to Montesquieu, who in 1748 described three branches of government, and it holds that the legislative, executive and judicial powers of the State should not all be placed in the same hands. His real concern was with the separation of functions. This was explained by James Madison in the Federalist Papers, where he said that liberty is lost when the whole power of one department is exercised by the same hands that hold the whole power of another, but that this does not mean the departments must have no partial share in, or control over, each other's acts. The reasons are practical. If the same body makes the law and carries it out, it may make harsh laws and apply them harshly, and if the judge were also the legislator, the life and liberty of the subject would be at the mercy of arbitrary power. The idea of a partial share and of control is now called the system of checks and balances.
The American Constitution gives this theory a direct form. It vests all legislative powers in Congress, the executive power in the President, and the judicial power in the Supreme Court and the lower courts that Congress may set up.
The Indian Constitution does not follow this pattern. The question was considered by the Constituent Assembly. Professor K T Shah proposed a draft Article 40-A saying that there shall be complete separation of powers between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary. It was opposed in the Assembly, one member pointing out that it made no sense to say that a few judges are better than the many members chosen by the people. Dr Ambedkar replied that the Constitution already contained an article in the directive principles, now Article 50, which separates the judiciary from the executive. As for separating the executive from the legislature, he said that the work of Parliament is so large and complicated that its members need the direct guidance of the members of the executive sitting in Parliament. The motion was put to the vote and was defeated. The framers therefore considered the American model of strict separation and chose the parliamentary system, in which the executive and the legislature work closely together, while the judiciary is kept apart from both.
The Supreme Court has held the same. In A K Roy v Union of India (1982) it said that the Constitution does not follow the American pattern of a strict separation of powers. The text of the Constitution shows why. The President is a part of Parliament and has legislative power to make ordinances under Article 123, and the Governor has the same power under Article 213. The courts also make rules, the Supreme Court under Article 145 and the High Courts under Articles 227 and 229. The President and the Governors decide questions of disqualification of members under Articles 103 and 192. The Speaker decides disputes about defection. The Supreme Court performs an executive function in appointing its staff under Article 146. The High Courts have administrative control over the subordinate courts and tribunals under Articles 227 and 229. Tribunals set up by statute decide disputes between parties with something like the powers of a court, although they belong to the executive side, and the writ jurisdiction of the courts is always available against their decisions. Parliament, too, exercises a judicial function in the removal of judges under Articles 124(5) and 217, and in dealing with contempt of the legislature under Article 194(3). The whole of delegated legislation is a further example. What the Constitution forbids is therefore not an overlap of functions, since there is a good deal of it, but the takeover of one organ's essential function by another.
The Supreme Court summarised the law in State of Tamil Nadu v State of Kerala ((2014) 12 SCC 696). The doctrine of separation of powers, though not expressly set out in the Constitution, is plainly visible in its scheme, and the Constitution has drawn demarcations between the three organs without drawing formal lines. The independence of the courts from the executive and the legislature is fundamental to the rule of law and is one of the basic tenets of the Constitution. The separation of powers is also a consequence of the principle of equality in Article 14, and a law may be struck down for breach of the separation of powers since such a breach is a negation of equality. The legislature cannot declare a decision of a court void or of no effect. It can, however, pass an amending Act to remove the defects the court has pointed out, or change the basis of the decision. If the legislature has power over the subject, it may make the law at any time and may even give it retrospective effect. Yet a law that seems to be within the competence of the legislature may be invalid if, in substance, it is an attempt to interfere with the judicial process.
The principle is recognised in the basic structure doctrine as well. The separation of powers between the legislature, the executive and the judiciary appears in the lists of basic features of the Constitution, which means that Parliament cannot remove it even by an amendment. But a violation of the separation of powers does not have to be so serious as to amount to an abrogation of the basic structure before it becomes unconstitutional (Mohmadhusen A K Shaikh v Union of India, (2009) 2 SCC 1).
Two other features of the Constitution add to the picture. Article 50 in the directive principles provides for the separation of the judiciary from the executive, so the idea of an independent judiciary is written into the Constitution itself. And the Constitution gives the judiciary the power of judicial review without making it supreme, since the final power to change the Constitution lies with Parliament, subject to the basic structure. Taken together, these show that the Indian Constitution follows a flexible separation of functions with checks and balances, and not a rigid division of powers.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
