X a Kshatriya male died leaving two wives (Kshatriya & Brahmin), two sons by each wife, adopted son, daughter, mother. How would you distribute the property?
Identifying the Heirs
X, a Kshatriya male, dies intestate after the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 came into force. The question does not say when the marriages took place or whether the property is coparcenary, so it is assumed that both marriages were solemnised before 18 May 1955, when the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 came into force, and that the property is X's separate property. He leaves behind the following survivors:
Wife W₁, the Kshatriya wife (valid marriage)
Wife W₂, the Brahmin wife (valid marriage, pre-1955)
S₁ and S₂, two sons by W₁
S₃ and S₄, two sons by W₂
AS, an adopted son
D, a daughter
M, the mother
The crucial preliminary question is whether both wives are entitled to succeed. The Hindu Succession Act does not define "widow", but only a woman whose marriage to the intestate was valid is his widow. Polygamous marriages contracted before the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 came into force remain valid, so on the assumption above both W₁ and W₂ are widows and Class I heirs. The wives' different castes make no difference.
The Adopted Son's Position
The adopted son stands on precisely the same footing as a natural-born son. Section 12 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 provides that an adopted child is deemed to be the child of the adoptive father or mother for all purposes from the date of the adoption. The Hindu Succession Act, in Section 3(1)(a) and (c), treats relationship by adoption as relationship by blood. AS is therefore a son in every respect, equal in entitlement to S₁, S₂, S₃ and S₄.
Section 18 Does Not Arise
The sons by W₁ and the sons by W₂ are half-brothers to each other, but that relationship does not affect their claims against X.
Section 18 prefers an heir related by full blood to one related by half blood where the relationship is the same in every other respect. All the sons, whether by W₁, W₂ or adoption, stand in the same relationship to X, namely that of son, and each is related to X by full blood. Section 18 therefore does not apply.
The half-blood distinction exists only between the sons themselves and not between any son and X, so no son is excluded. All the sons, the adopted son and the daughter inherit together as Class I heirs.
Computing the Shares, Section 10 Rules
The property is to be distributed among Class I heirs. The applicable heads are:
Both widows together → one share (Rule 1: if there are more widows than one, all widows together take one share)
Each surviving son (S₁, S₂, S₃, S₄, and AS) → one share each (Rule 2)
Daughter D → one share (Rule 2)
Mother M → one share (Rule 2)
Counting the shares:
Widows together: 1 share
S₁: 1 share
S₂: 1 share
S₃: 1 share
S₄: 1 share
AS (adopted son): 1 share
D: 1 share
M: 1 share
Total: 8 shares
Each share therefore equals 1/8 of the estate.
| Heir | Share |
|---|---|
| W₁ + W₂ together | 1/8 |
| W₁ individually | 1/16 |
| W₂ individually | 1/16 |
| S₁ | 1/8 |
| S₂ | 1/8 |
| S₃ | 1/8 |
| S₄ | 1/8 |
| AS (adopted son) | 1/8 |
| Daughter D | 1/8 |
| Mother M | 1/8 |
The Widows' Share
The two widows, between themselves, divide the one share equally, each taking 1/16. Rule 1 of Section 10 provides that several widows together take one share, so that they do not increase the widow's share. The rule is meant for pre-1955 polygamous marriages, which is this case.
A wife of a void marriage, such as a second marriage contracted after the Hindu Marriage Act in breach of Section 5(i), is not a widow for this purpose (Mallipeddy Sheshaiah v. N. Tulasamma, AIR 2005 AP 221). If either of X's marriages post-dated 18 May 1955, that wife would not be a widow and the shares would change. The property is also assumed to be separate property. If X was a Mitakshara coparcener, Section 6 would apply.
Caste
Under the older Hindu law the caste of the wives could affect their rights. Section 4 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 overrides any text, rule or interpretation of Hindu law and any custom or usage inconsistent with the Act, so the caste of a widow does not affect her inheritance.
Summary of Distribution
The estate of X devolves in eight equal shares: five sons (four natural, one adopted), one daughter, the mother, and both widows together. The mother inherits with the sons and daughter, since she is a Class I heir (Sections 8 and 9). X's caste, the different castes of the wives and the adoption do not alter the shares under Section 10.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
