Limitation ActComputation of Period of Limitation 06 July 2026· 4 min read

    X wanted to institute a suit against Y for breach of contract. Goods were delivered on 12.11.2011 in Yamuna Nagar. X files suit in Faridabad on 06.06.2013. On 08.10.2014, court dismisses suit for lack of jurisdiction. X institutes suit in Yamuna Nagar on 20.11.2014. Discuss rules of computation of limitation period and decide the case.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The first thing to settle is the period. A claim arising from goods delivered on 12 November 2011 falls under a three-year article. If the claim is for the price of goods sold and delivered, the article is Article 14, with time running from delivery where no period of credit was fixed. If it is for compensation for breach of the contract, Article 55 applies, with time running from the date of the breach. The facts do not say which, and nothing turns on it, because both give three years and both are taken here to start on 12 November 2011.

    Section 12(1) excludes the day from which the period is to be reckoned, so the period begins on 13 November 2011 and, counting three years, ends on 12 November 2014. Considered by itself, the fresh suit filed in Yamuna Nagar on 20 November 2014 is eight days late. The whole case therefore depends on whether the time spent in Faridabad can be excluded under section 14.

    Section 14(1) excludes the time during which the plaintiff has been prosecuting with due diligence another civil proceeding against the defendant, where the proceeding relates to the same matter in issue and is prosecuted in good faith in a court which, from defect of jurisdiction or other cause of a like nature, is unable to entertain it. Applying the conditions, the first suit and the second are both civil suits by X against Y on the same breach, so the parties and the matter in issue are the same. The Faridabad court dismissed the suit for lack of jurisdiction, so the earlier proceeding failed for a defect of the kind the section covers; territorial jurisdiction is a defect of jurisdiction for this purpose. Both proceedings were in courts. What remains is the requirement of due diligence and good faith, which is a question of fact. If X filed in Faridabad on a reasonable view of the contract, for example because Y carried on business there or because of a term of the agreement that was arguably read as conferring jurisdiction there, and then prosecuted the suit without delay, the condition is met. A bona fide mistake about the place of suing is exactly the kind of mistake the section is meant to protect, and the courts have not required the plaintiff to be right, only to have acted with due care and attention (Deena v Bharat Singh, (2002) 6 SCC 336 : AIR 2002 SC 2768). If, on the other hand, the contract plainly fixed the forum at Yamuna Nagar and X chose Faridabad with no reason except convenience, or kept the suit pending without taking the obvious steps to have the question of jurisdiction decided, the benefit could be refused.

    Where the Faridabad court is said to have dismissed the suit, it should be noted that in practice a court without jurisdiction returns the plaint for presentation to the proper court, and the result is the same either way. The computation then follows the Explanation to section 14. The excluded period runs from the day the Faridabad suit was instituted, 6 June 2013, to the day it ended, 8 October 2014, and both days are counted. That is 490 days. The days excluded are added to the end of the prescribed period, so the last day, 12 November 2014, moves forward by 490 days to 16 March 2016. The suit filed in Yamuna Nagar on 20 November 2014 is therefore well within that date.

    The same result appears if the days are counted the other way. From 13 November 2011 to 5 June 2013, before the first suit, 571 days had run. After the dismissal, the days from 9 October 2014 to 20 November 2014 add 43. The total counted against X is 614 days, a little under two years, against a period of three years. The 490 days spent in Faridabad are simply left out.

    The decision is that the suit filed in Yamuna Nagar is within limitation, provided X satisfies the court that the Faridabad suit was prosecuted with due diligence and in good faith. On the facts as stated, that is the likely finding, since the first suit was filed within time, was pursued to a decision, and was dismissed for want of jurisdiction, and X sued in the proper court within some six weeks of the dismissal. X should plead the facts of the earlier proceeding in the plaint and claim the exclusion under section 14, since the court will not apply it unless the facts are before it. Y's remaining argument, that the six-week gap between the dismissal and the fresh suit is unexplained, does not matter, because the total time counted is still far below the period of three years.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.